MrBeast’s former manager Reed Duchscher, says the age of social-media superstars is fading: “As social-media algorithms get better at tailoring content to individual user interests, the opportunity for stars to show up across feeds becomes much harder,” Duchscher said.

https://www.businessinsider.com/mrbeast-former-manager-says-age-of-social-giants-is-fading-2025-12

35 Comments

  1. I skipped this phase entirely. I really never understood why these awful, toxic, juvenile, nuisance personalities became so popular. Who looks at Mr. Beast or Logan Paul or these other cretins and says, “this resonates with me! I need to subscribe and see more”? Apparently a lot of people.

  2. I mean, not really? It means that there will be more specialized creators. Little Timmy who watches pokemon content will see more pokemon focused creators instead of seeing Mr beast all over

  3. I’d argue the exact opposite. The algorithm biases the videos that do well. The small time creators never get plays where the Mr beasts of the world get suggested because they do well. It concentrates the viewership to the mega stars

  4. Let’s be honest here, no one on social media is truly a star. They are all pockets of gas that don’t really shine.

  5. Except the “MrBeasts” of the world only happened *because* of tailored algorithmic feeds. We started funneling people into narrow bands of media based on interests, trending, and paid-for placement. While its true that a smaller person *just starting* has to fight to get into that slot its not because they lack content that gets into people’s feeds but that they lack the viewership, sponsors, watch time, or other metrics that most feeds prefer before *allowing* you appear to a broader audience. While unrelated in a way, its like how Youtube limits how many viewers you can have based on subscribers: prevents people from hitting the front page doing something they shouldn’t be doing (e.g. going out with a bang.) But the same restriction means a new person needs to fight that much harder compared to 5 years ago when you could just viewbot your way to the top and quickly establish yourself. Its not that anybody actually *wanted to see you* but that the algorithm, seeing how “popular” you are, now pushes you to everybody’s feed.

  6. I hate that social media has stars. I don’t give a fuck how good someone is as gaming the algorithm (which is what Mr Beast and his empty eyes is good at)… I want people that actually have something to offer society. Music, art, acting, teaching.

  7. The more followers an individual has*, the less interested in them I become. I just wanna see normal people doing stuff I’m interested in, not entitled people being materialistic and performative.

    *(on YouTube, the only place I ‘follow’ people)

  8. I suspect it’s also down to the fact more and more use the “don’t recommend anything from this channel” function more and more.

    At one point YouTube learns not to show me stupid content like that

  9. What_Is_This_1 on

    Not true. They just gotta play to the algorithm. Make it happy…say the right ideas…don’t do anything that’ll upset anyone and they’ll make it big…nothings changed. Just the rules have become more strict.

  10. Massive-Ride204 on

    Yeah I see what he’s saying, and I think we’re already starting to see it especially in regards to famous people and celebrities. I think there will still be some that can be famous across the board but they will dwindle on number.

    Fame will be on a much more micro level where someone will be famous only in a specific, genre or subculture

  11. DishwashingUnit on

    Oh wow at some point the algorithm is going to start generating us custom videos and then different media companies are going to start buying an intellectual property and the algorithm is eventually going to start spitting at me custom fucking Star Trek.

  12. Let’s not kid ourselves, social media algorithms aren’t going to get better at doing anything but serving the interests of their billionaire owners and whatever political agenda they have at the moment.

  13. Influencers/social media celebs are parasites, for the most part. I cant say they are all bad, that wouldn’t be fair, but it seems like most of them are just kind one and the same. I hate how just any uninteresting person, can all of a sudden make themselves into a brand. Just labeling them “influencers” puts them on a pedestal and gives off this sense of importance.

    This phase of broccoli headed dorks/thick eye brow girls, needs to come to an end. And while Im at it, stop with the forced positivity and lame overreactions, especially to simple things. Thats also annoying.

    “Ohhh my GOD, he did NOT just dip his fry into that shake. That is DIABOLICAL!”

  14. givin_u_the_high_hat on

    Once something democratic where ordinary people become successful, corporate interests will always take over. If there’s money flowing, they want to be sure it’s flowing to them.

  15. the_party_galgo on

    Thank goodness. My YouTube is strictly about my interests and I would not have it any other way. I legit have no idea who are the biggest YouTubers and didn’t know about Mr Beast for a while.