Moscow, Russia - 27 September 2023: Tesla Model Y all electric car driving down the street

Image Credit: Haggardous50000 at Shutterstock.

Tesla is facing mounting legal headaches in the United Kingdom after being repeatedly fined for failing to cooperate with police over traffic violations committed by its drivers. Over the past two years, the British arm of the electric car giant has accumulated at least 18 convictions and been ordered to pay more than $27,000 (£20,000) in fines and court costs.

The cases highlight a legal obligation in the UK that may be unfamiliar to American drivers. In Britain, when a leased or company-owned car is caught speeding, the police must identify the driver before prosecution can proceed.

If the registered keeper of the vehicle fails to provide the requested information, the company itself can be prosecuted. Tesla Financial Services, which handles the leases of many vehicles in the UK, has repeatedly run afoul of this system.

SELINAS, CA, USA - Red Tesla Model S on the highway

Image Credit: Cassiohabib at Shutterstock.

One of the incidents that landed Tesla in court involved a vehicle clocked at 80 mph (128 km/h) on the M4 highway near Llantrisant, South Wales, in July 2025. South Wales Police sent a formal request to Tesla Financial Services to identify the driver, but the company failed to respond in a timely and adequate manner.

In a court filing, Tesla director Becky Hodgson admitted the company had faced “technical issues” when attempting to enter a plea online. She argued that internal processes had been followed and that the information had been sent by post.

The court did not accept this explanation and fined Tesla £1,000 (around $1,400), with an additional $165 (£120) in court costs and a $551 (£400) victim surcharge.

While a £1,000 fine may sound modest by US standards, the broader pattern is significant. The Press Association has identified 18 separate convictions since the start of 2024, including prosecutions brought by the Metropolitan Police, Hampshire Constabulary, and Thames Valley Police.

In some cases, Tesla drivers were caught speeding multiple times. Because the company failed to identify the drivers, courts imposed penalties on Tesla rather than on individual drivers, a situation that could have serious reputational consequences for the automaker in Europe.

Tesla Model X

Photo Courtesy: Tesla.

One notable case involved a driver traveling nearly 100 mph (160 km/h) on the A3 in Petersfield, Hampshire. Because police letters went unanswered, the speeding driver remained unidentified, and Tesla Financial Services received the conviction.

Another case saw a driver caught speeding on three separate occasions. If identified, the driver could have faced disqualification from driving, but Tesla’s lack of cooperation meant the company, rather than the driver, bore the legal consequences.

Across the identified cases, magistrates sitting in the single justice procedure—used in the UK for minor offenses—have imposed fines, costs, and court fees totaling $28,486 (£20,686). Letters from police were reportedly sent to multiple Tesla offices in London and Manchester, as well as a service center.

Despite these repeated notices, the company’s responses were deemed insufficient by the courts.

tesla model s long range

Image Credit: logoboom / Shutterstock.com.

There is an open question here about whether Tesla is deliberately walking the same tightrope Apple has famously embraced, prioritizing customer privacy even when it creates friction with authorities. Tesla vehicles generate vast amounts of driver data, and handing over driver identities on demand could set precedents the company may be wary of.

From that perspective, the fines may be viewed internally as a cost of maintaining a strong privacy posture. Still, courts appear unconvinced by that framing, and repeated convictions suggest that privacy principles, if that is the motivation, are colliding with clear legal obligations Tesla cannot simply opt out of.

The cases underscore the challenges automakers face in balancing customer privacy with legal compliance. In the UK, unlike in the US, the law directly holds vehicle lease providers responsible for identifying drivers in traffic investigations.

American readers may recognize parallels in how rental car companies sometimes provide driver information to law enforcement, but UK law makes failing to respond a prosecutable offense.

Tesla has been asked to comment on the ongoing legal matters, but the company has not publicly responded.

Sources: BBC

Comments are closed.