According to statistics, as many as 41% of new jobs in the EU are created in Spain. Yes, a lot of these are eating away at the country's chronically high unemployment rate, but Spain has a number of massive advantages over other EU countries and G20 members.

Migration and demography: Spain has a massive reservoir of potential migrant workers (Latin Americans) who already speak the language and so will basically become integrated and productive citizens on Day One if they can get work permits. Completely the opposite to most other European countries, which either speak unique languages or which historically didn't try to educate or integrate their colonial subjects. (Yes, there were A TON of abuses within the Spanish empire, but historically they were a lot more enlightened on things like ancestry and skin color than the British or French.) This large population of potential well-integrated Spaniards puts Spain at a huge advantage over other European nations, where few non-EU citizens speak the language and/or those that do were historically demonized by racist colonizers.

This is already beginning to lift Spain into the top tier of EU players. Where other rich countries are violently reacting against even legal immigrants, Spain is regularizing hundreds of thousands of mainly Latin American migrants who often came on work visas. That will only be strengthened if the US remains repulsive to Hispanic communities, including American citizens and legal permanent residents. Significant parts of Latin America still have near-replacement level or even above-replacement level fertility, including the Andes and parts of Central America, meaning that Spain's fertility problem isn't nearly as urgent as it looks. And this may be controversial, but I'd imagine that the diverse facial features among Spanish-speaking peoples would make it easier to integrate migrants in general if they can pass for Dominican or Cuban or Venezuelan or Peruvian. This contrasts with the UK or France or the Netherlands, where there historically has been a much sharper color line within their linguistic spheres due to segregation.

Renewables and energy: Spain has a separate utility grid from most of the EU and an abundance of sunlight. As long as it takes basic measures to prevent a repeat of the recent power outage, Spain is well positioned for the energy tradition. It also has a lot of walkable cities and a pretty good train network, even if there have been a couple safety lapses.

Excess land: Although cost of living is really high in the megacities, Spain paradoxically has a ton of rural and small town areas that already have roads and infrastructure but have been bleeding population for decades. Properly mandating or pushing for remote and hybrid work could fix Spain's cost of living problem tomorrow if the government has the cojones to do it. And yes, agglomeration economies are important for continued growth in tech in particular…but does Spain really need more poor-quality GDP growth coming from tech bros? Or could it be better served by revitalizing places like Soria with hybrid and remote workers? There are big chunks of "empty Spain" within two hours' train ride from central Madrid and Barcelona that could easily be filled up with hybrid commuters, basically solving the country's housing problem with the stroke of a pen.

Spain could be in for a promising future as a middle power.
byu/RRY1946-2019 inFuturology

7 Comments

  1. hikingmaterial on

    I think you are heavily confusing “available basic manpower” with the bright future you paint. less unemployment is but a small stept towards development, the rest is done with public education and significant investment, neither of which the new entrants contribute to, wether from south america or morocco.

    these are generally people with limited education and skills who have overstayed their time in spain, and after their govts legalisation, will likely work in the hospitality and tourism sector, which doesnt really advance spains development.

    they are also going so heavily against the grain of the rest of the EU, that I dont really see this future you are painting.

  2. Narcisistagohome on

    Yeah, but there is a constant in Spanish history that uses to frustrate these develioments: its reactionary elite.

    There are many legit criticism against the current government, but it’s true that the are played certain cards very well and gave put Spain in the direction of a deep economical transformation, an structural one, what others tried and failed. 

    But, as soon as a PP-Vox coalition takes power, they will reverse all t y e policies causing this because “woke”, because “waste of money” or whatever other bullshit. Big money wants Spain as it is, low salaries, low culture and submissive. 

  3. As somebody from Canada, too much immigration even if they speak the language is still a bad thing. There’s only so many jobs and land a country can support. I only had to google a little to see that 1/4 of all young people are unemployed and overall 10% of the population is unemployed in Spain. The real statistic is rumored to be higher. Spain already can not support its current population with jobs or maintain an environment to create ENOUGH jobs.

    And you can see from Canada too another lesson is that immigration doesn’t always lead to GDP growth, it can be the exact opposite as it can still contract. What happens then is you have a lot of people on even more generous social programs while the country is starting to generate less money.

    You also criticize tech, but that’s how many areas outside of the urban centers are seeing population growth and revitalization. As these jobs can generally be done at ones home computer away from the city. People criticized this for gentrifying more rural areas but that’s a different topic.

    Use Canada as an example on what to NOT do. Not replicating it in the name of ideology that immigration must always continue at record highs.

  4. You have an extremely idealistic and frankly naive and ignorant view of how migration dynamics truly work.

    Giving amnesty to a ton of people who just wandered into your country because you’re too weak to kick them out, is not a sudden economic super boost. It’s a slow suicide.

    Do you think highly capable, intelligent, skilled people who have the ability to improve the country foundations, just hop borders and break laws and hope they get amnesty from the weak government?

  5. BrokkelPiloot on

    I agree with most of your points. However,.having a separate utility grid is a big downside. You actually want to be as interconnected as possible with neighbouring countries.
    Just ask Texas 😛

  6. I’m going to say, pretty sure that the entire conversation is run by a bot.

    Has bot / AI like responses which means anything you write then becomes its source.

    Dejalo y encuentra mejores opciones.

    Leave it and find better sources.

  7. ladeedah1988 on

    Visited Spain several times over the last few years and have been so impressed with infrastructure, their cities, but mostly the attitude of their population which is overwhelmingly positive. I have felt they have an advantage for the future over Germany and France.