A section of the NECEC corridor in Johnson Mountain Township is covered with straw in November 2021. Crews put down the straw for erosion control. (Staff photo by Gregory Rec/Staff Photographer)

    AUGUSTA — The Maine Board of Environmental Protection delayed final consideration Thursday of the validity of the conservation area associated with the controversial New England Clean Energy Connect transmission line.

    The board met for five hours in the Augusta Armory to consider an appeal from environmental groups, which argued the project’s conservation plan did not meet standards for habitat connectivity and mature forest conservation. The board had ordered the conservation plan in 2022 to mitigate habitat disruption caused by the NECEC transmission line, which cut a 150-foot-wide swath through rural, forested landscape.

    Members of the board said Thursday that they need more information from the Department of Environmental Protection staff to determine if the area does, in fact, mitigate the disruption of habitat. They did not say when they would make a final decision.

    But officials appeared skeptical of NECEC’s arguments.

    “I’m not convinced there’s any mitigation whatsoever,” board Chair Robert Duschene said.

    After nearly a decade of litigation, appeals and political wrangling, the project went online in January, connecting 1,200 megawatts of Canadian hydropower to Massachusetts consumers.

    Thursday’s decision kept the final state of the project in limbo. It’s unlikely that a board decision on the conservation area would impact the already-ongoing operation of the line, but environmental groups say approving the company’s plan could set a dangerous precedent for other large-scale projects to proceed without following strict habitat protection guidelines.

    Maine Board of Environmental Protection members listen Thursday to arguments from attorney David Kallin against the NECEC conservation area. Board members decided to ask for more information on mature forests, prolonging a decade-long battle for one final step. (Ethan Horton/Staff Writer)

    The Board of Environmental Protection initially approved this conservation plan in November, saying it had significant conservation value and citing direct connections to more than 400,000 acres of other conserved land.

    Environmental groups appealed a month later, arguing NECEC’s conservation area did not meet the board’s standards.

    Forests in the area are heavily harvested by the landowner, Weyerhaeuser, the groups have long said, and the value of the conserved land didn’t meet habitat connectivity standards, given that it is split by U.S. Route 201 and other roads and transmission lines.

    The groups also said the conservation area did not protect “mature forests,” as required by the board’s order in 2022. LiDAR analysis of the area by forest ecologist John Hagan showed that less than 0.2% of the trees in the area were more than 100 years and than only 7% of the area was covered by trees over 50 feet tall.

    NECEC attorneys had asked the board to deny the appeal outright. Environmental groups asked the board to order NECEC to add more high-value, old-growth forest to the conservation area to compensate for the continual harvesting of the proposed 50,000 acres.

    The groups took issue with NECEC’s approach for this conservation area, where Weyerhaeuser would be allowed to log areas as they grow.

    Drummond Woodsum attorney David Kallin, representing the Appalachian Mountain Club, one of the appellants, argued that this approach would mean, in effect, that none of the forest would ever become mature — except for the 7,000 acres protected from cutting by their proximity to wetlands.

    But attorneys for NECEC said the environmental groups were the ones who proposed this region for conservation in the first place, and that the board did not set the stringent definition for forest maturity that environmental groups were advocating for.

    “This appeal is a complete about-face,” NECEC attorney Lisa Gilbreath told board members.

    And, Gilbreath said, it would be near-impossible for NECEC to find land nearby that meets the high standard of the board’s order.

    Staff for the Department of Environmental Protection had recommended that the board deny the appeal, but board members said they didn’t agree with the basis of the draft order.

    DEP staff will return to the board with more information and a new draft order, but board members did not say when they will finally decide on the conservation area.

    Share.

    Comments are closed.