Lorin Scicluna was offered a 30-year plea bargain for the murder of Lassana Cisse, but he refused the deal and opted for a trial.
Times of Malta is informed that Scicluna’s defence team secured the plea bargain days before the trial was scheduled.
Instead of taking the deal, he instructed his lawyers to go for a trial.
Scicluna was acquitted on Sunday by a nine-person jury of murdering Lassana Cisse and trying to murder Mohammed Jallow, Ibrahim Bah and May Malimi.
However, he was found guilty of causing grievous bodily harm to May Malimi, aggravated by the fact that it was racially motivated. He was also found guilty of using a vehicle without registration plates.
In the bill of indictment, the Attorney General sought a prison term of between 18 months and nine years for grievous bodily harm aggravated by racial hatred.
Under Article 216 of the Criminal Code, grievous bodily harm carries a maximum prison sentence of seven years. However, Article 83 allows for a harsher sentence when the crime is motivated by racial hatred.
A judge will deliver the final sentence on Wednesday at 12.30pm.
Cisse was walking home after watching a football match on April 6, 2019, when he was shot along Triq il-Ġebel, the road linking Ħal Far and Birżebbuġa.
Scicluna’s defence during the trial was that his friend Francesco Fenech had fired the shots that killed Cisse and injured the two other men.
Fenech faces separate criminal proceedings over the same killing.
The acquittal has led to outrage among civil society voices.
Matthew Caruana Galizia called for the jury system to be scrapped. The verdict followed the acquittal two months ago of Yorgen Fenech for the murder of his mother Daphne Caruana Galizia.
Andre Callus, an activist with Moviment Graffitti, warned that the verdict reflected deeper problems within Maltese society.
Labour Party president Alex Sciberras was also in disbelief after the verdict. He said people must find the courage to confront racism without minimising it.
“When we begin to see someone merely as a foreigner, a burden or a threat, we lose the ability to see ourselves in them,” he wrote.
Academic Maria Pisani, who accompanied Cisse’s body to Ivory Coast for burial, said “decades of institutional racism” indirectly led to the acquittal.
‘No one needs a plea deal if they are innocent’
In a statement, The Daphne Caruana Galizia Foundation called for drastic reform to the justice system, which “rubber-stamped” Cisse’s murder by acquitting Scicluna, it said.
“Scicluna’s lawyers secured a 30-year plea deal before he was acquitted. No one needs a plea deal if they are innocent, just as no one asks for a pardon if they are not guilty – as Yorgen Fenech did five times for the murder of the journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia,” the statement reads.
The foundation said the jury system is vulnerable to abuse. The fact that jurors present verdicts without proving rationale “undermines transparency, leaves both the prosecution and the defence without clarity, and severely limits the possibility of filing effective appeals”, it said.
Jurors are also susceptible to public campaigns, prejudice and influence, the foundation said. “All of these factors jeopardise the guarantee of an impartial trial. Jurors do not typically have specialised knowledge and training, unlike members of the judiciary who are familiar with the law and trained to discern the facts before them impartially.”
“As in Yorgen Fenech’s trial, the jurors’ questions showed they did not understand the basic legal concept of complicity in murder. The jurors ignored what matters, which is that two people went out armed with a gun with the intention to kill black people, and that made them both complicit in murder.”
Sign up to our free newsletters
Get the latest stories and updates from Times of Malta delivered straight to your inbox.
