This past week we have had a second criminal jury where the Prosecution has been unable to obtain a conviction for murder. Another trial, like the one in the previous month, that caught the people in tenterhooks with the popular expectation would have been a guilty on all charges, not least because of the abominable underlying crimes, one being a murder of a journalist critical of the government and capable of unravelling so much government corruption, and the other an altogether innocent murder victim, in the wrong place at the wrong time, and killed merely because of the colour of his skin.

    In both cases, many have resorted to a witch hunt against the jurors involved. Identified, named and shamed. Accused of being bribed and of taking false oaths. Having their phones somehow tapped and splashed in the public arena. Some were arrested, placed on police jail and left high and dry, under suspicion, ostracised by the common people. Little thought has been spared about the personal sacrifice of the jurors for many weeks in succession, secluded form all form of social contact, and being hammered by the judge as to their duty that they can only convict if they have no reasonable doubt about the guilt of the accused. That in criminal matters, pro reo, any doubt must necessarily go in favour of the accused. That in western democratic societies it is held that it is a lesser evil that 10 guilty persons remain in liberty than one innocent person should end up in jail for life.

    Little questioning has been made as to whether we ought to stop blaming the jurors and instead start blaming the prosecution, often manned with rather novice lawyers at the Office of the Attorney General, with the AG herself never ever making a show of support or presence during trials.

    The AG office has been allowed over time to get weaker with the departure of more experienced prosecutors, often kicked upstairs as Magistrates. The AG herself is continuously at the brunt of strong criticism, often justifiably, but inevitably taking its toll on the moral of the rest of the AG’s staff who have to toil and do their best according to the tools and the legislation in place and which has been crying for reform since generations but which has been left to rust inexorably.

    Malta owes justice to a long list of recent victims of murder: Daphne Caruana Galizia, Sion Grech, Paulina Dembska, Bernice Cassar, Pelin Kaya, Charlotte Zammit, Mary Grace Cassar, Miriam Azzopardi and others.

    But in our (panicked) quest for justice, we need to exercise profound reflection to ensure that we reform with rationality, without allowing hate or extremism to take the better of us, without throwing overboard that which is still valid or salvable.

    I have long advocated in public the following proposals which I consider auspicable in the field of the administration of justice. Long before the murder trials in the Daphne and Cisse cases.

    1. A root and branch reform of the trial by jury institute in our Criminal Code.

    The current trial by jury provisions remain substantively the same as those inherited from the British in the 19th century.

    The British have long reformed it in order to cope with new exigencies and advances of technology and forensic methods. The Maltese Parliamentarians have slept on it.

    Our elected representative have been bent to ensure that nothing of substance changes with the result that today we have a trial by jury system that is inadequate to deal with today’s circumstances. Each time a major jury delivers a verdict which popular opinion, or a rowdy part of it, did not expect, there is a major outcry about the unsuitability of the jury system. During these sorry aftermaths, the Rule of Law often takes a second place. Rational thought gives way to a modified Rule of Law, a sort of a Rule of Law a’ la carte. Remember the aftermath of the RCC juries in 2004 when both accused, in separate juries, Menraid Calleja and Ian Farrugia, were acquitted. And we are now at the tick of it again in the wake of the acquittal of Yorgen Fenech and now of Lorin Scicluna.

    The most glaring weakness is the composition of the jury panel. Having nine lay people, untrained in law and who suddenly find themselves doing something altogether different from their usual daily calling, determine the guilt or otherwise of the accused, with all the potential dangers of undue influence for the untrained, with the danger of being especially susceptible to irrelevant emotional influences, calls out for immediate reform whereby at least one, or perhaps even better three, members of they jury would be active or retired members of the judiciary. As is so commonplace in most other countries in continental Europe.

    Then we can perhaps also introduce the need for the jury panel to motivate its verdict for the various counts.

    But, like a diligent surgeon, our intervention must not be unnecessarily invasive.

    The jury institute has overall served us well over the centuries, both in Malta and abroad, and what is needed is its correction. Those calling for its outright abolition are over reacting. Nothing is infallible. We have had one, two and three cases of judges being bribed, and bribed in connection with criminal trials. The main element of trials by jury, that of the determination of factual guilt or innocence by a panel of ordinary citizens should remain. Surgery is needed, but it must be administered with key hole precision that does not inflict unnecessary collateral damage. We must not throw out the baby with the bath water.

    2. The removal of the duplicitous procedure of the compilation of evidence.

    Again, this procedure was introduced in our legislative corpus by the British. Except that the British have long ago repealed it. It does not exist in any other jurisdiction in Europe I know of. Nor in the US, Canada or Australia.

    Our compilation of evidence stage is in theory meant to preserve evidence but in reality it does anything except that. The testimony needs to be re-enacted many years later, with the intervening adverse consequences as a result of change in legislation, the inevitable loss of memory of details of witnesses, ensuing undue influence of witnesses in the intervening period, endless confrontation of witnesses, passing away of key witnesses and investigators, resigned police investigators giving evidence without reference to their files, stolen or lost pieces of evidential artifices in custody of the court registry.

    This compilation of justice stage is serving no useful purpose other than to cause a delay of long years until trials take place.

    Indeed, the trial by jury in the Daphne Caruana Galizia case 9 years after the murder and that of Lassana Cisse after 7 years are relatively very quick by Maltese standards.

    In contrast, the Sion Grech murder jury took place in January 2023, 18 years after the murder occurred and 10 years after the Police arraigned the accused. A Ponzi-style fraud case revolving around the disappearance of hundreds of people’s life savings invested with a licensed investment services provider company in 2014 has not yet been allotted a date for commencement of the trial. Compare this with the Bernard Madoff’s Ponzi fraud of US$65 billion which took only 5 years to investigate, unravel and bring to an end criminal proceedings from when it was first discovered in 2009.

    3. Introduce a tariff for professional fees applicable to criminal lawyers.

    In the civil court, where hundreds of practicing lawyers toil and sweat in the pursuit of concluding their clients’ civil cases, there is an established tariff for calculating lawyers’ fees which are duly paid complete with VAT and visible and transparent to the Inland Revenue in terms of earnings by the practitioners.

    In the criminal field, it is a free-for-all, open for negotiation, or rather for ransom, with no limits, a similar phenomenon of legalised usury with high interest rates substituted for professional fees. The anecdotal evidence is that top tier penal lawyers’ fees are not in the thousands, nor tens of thousands, but hundreds of thousands, although millions by way of prize money have been mentioned as well.

    This is confirmed by the evidence during the Daphne trial and the mention of Yorgen Fenech assisting in the payment of defence lawyers to the tune of hundreds of thousands to a multitude of lawyers representing the wide web of suspects involved with the murder, evident to all except Hero Arnaud.

    The family of murdered Sion Grech did not manage to find a single lawyer to represent the victim’s family as parte civile. Not unless they came up with an €80,000 deposit which they could not afford. So the system lambasted them with a legal aid lawyer who evidently did not waste time in jury sessions in the interest of so unimportant and penniless family.

    Justice is not meant for lawyers, but for all ordinary people.

    We should no longer perpetuate a system that fleeces common citizens dry over a long period of years. The free for all currently prevailing insofar as penal lawyers’ services are concerned is denying common mortals access to the best form of representation in defence proceedings. A Justice Deficit example par excellence.

    4. The constitutional provisions covering the Commission for the Administration of Justice and those of the Commissioner for Standards of the Judiciary must be tightened.

    The Commission for the Administration of Justice, presided by the President of the Republic, is charged with investigating issues surrounding the judicial corps. It is empowered to look into potential breaches of the Code of Ethics or matters concerning the proper functioning of the courts on it is own motion, more commonly known ex ufficio. But it is not obliged to do so and it cannot be forced to investigate any matter. Even when and if it does so, it does not give account to the public of the results and all is shrouded in secrecy.

    The Commissioner for Judicial Standards is impeded by the law from taking up any matter in respect of which no complaint has been received. He must behave like the three monkeys, however obvious to him that something ought to be investigated.

    We have all heard of the (not allowed) communications, earlier this year, between an active judge and a Prime Minister by WhatsApp, an instrument credited with being impenetrable because of end-to-end encryption.

    We have all witnessed the evidence in Court delivered by the AG prosecutor during the Daphne jury whereby a decree by a Magistrate (by mere co-incidence soon after appointed Judge), which revoked an earlier decree of another Magistrate (by mere co-incidence soon after resigning “for personal reasons”) and which dealt a mortal blow to the request for an inquiry into the 17 Black case, was sent to interested parties many hours before it was delivered. It was a sort of draft sent to interested parties to see if it fitted exactly with their expectations. Who leaked this? An intruder? The Magistrate himself? The staff in his Chambers?

    What followed in both cases was dead silence from the Prime Minister, Judge and Magistrate involved. From the Commission for the Administration of Justice. From the anachronistically named Camera degli Avvocati. From the Minister of Justice. And indeed dead silence also from the Leader of the Opposition and the manifestly conflicted penal judge acting as Shadow Minister for Justice.

    How do Parliamentarians and the Judicial corps expect the common citizen to have faith in the Courts delivering justice in the wake of all this distressing evidence, evidence which somehow reached the public arena and which, judging by the cockroach syndrome, must be much more commonplace in reality?

    5. Finally, but most importantly, a constitutional change that is crying for reform is that of the appointment of the Police Commissioner and that of the Attorney General. Such appointments should carry a two-thirds majority, similar to the appointment of the Chief Justice, the Ombudsman and the NAO Commissioner.

    There can never be a really impartial and independent and exhaustive investigation of crimes and prosecution of criminals, without fear or favour, unless the Commissioner of Police and the Attorney General has security of tenure and do not owe their continuance in their post only because of the Prime Minister’s whim and favour.

    We have had a long list of Police Commissioners since self-government in 1947. The only one that was capable of resisting a Prime Minister’s wrath was Vivian de Gray, whose post did not depend on the favour of the Prime Minister. All others succeeding him, bar a couple with enough strong personality not to have made a big mess, have all succumbed to government pressure. One has been convicted of murder. Another has conspired with criminals, tipping off and passing official secrets to prime suspects as we all witnessed during the DCG trial.

    This is probably the most important single reform. We must start from there. Anything less does not guarantee anything will change for the future, irrespective of Opposition Party speeches and Council of Europe evaluation reports.

    Prime Minister, have some courage. Give the nation that has entrusted you once more with its leadership and do something really beneficial for the people in the field of Justice. Give up your prerogative to appoint these top posts. Otherwise your oft repeated call to trust the institutions is nothing other than hollow, sarcastic and offensive

    I trust my appeal to the legislative power of this country will not be lost for fear of change or that of irritating the untouchables.

    The proposals I make are meant to make justice reforms real and meaningful at the common citizen’s level and not only at the conceptual level. A reform that will benefit people irrespective of whether crime is somehow related or connected to politics or not. A reform that will benefit all the people.

    Successive Maltese governments since Independence, whether blue or red, had all the time in the world to radically reform the Criminal Code. But our Parliaments, dominated as they have always been by the legal profession, have effectively ensured that everything remains the same.

    Instead we have had piecemeal changes to our justice legislation, each time addressing a single issue with the hope that it will fix the unsatisfactory situation surrounding justice. The people of Malta deserve an over-arching holistic reform addressing all that has been left to rust and rot in the hope that we and our children can enjoy one of the most essential elements in a democratic society, a true and just administration of justice, without fear or favour, that ensures the law is really equal for all.

    I raise my J’Accuse to the big number of Maltese parliamentarians, bigger per capita than any other Parliament in the world.

    They have found the time of guaranteeing their own pension entitlements, with no maximum limit, earned with the passage of only two legislative stints rather than a 40-year duration for us common mortals and free from taxation. Get down from your high moral ground and please find the time and do something right for the benefit of your citizens:

    REFORM JUSTICE HOLISTICALLY IN THE INTEREST OF THE COMMON CITIZEN.

    Paul Bonello is a financial journalist and political observer.

    Lovin Malta is open to interesting, compelling guest posts from third parties. These opinion pieces do not necessarily reflect the views of the company. Submit your piece at [email protected]

    READ NEXT: Is The Economy Serving Us, Or Are We Serving The Economy?

    Share.

    Comments are closed.