There are few things more emblematic of the holiday consumer economy than the advent calendar. What was once a relatively simple countdown to Christmas has become another opportunity for brands to package anticipation, exclusivity and the promise of a little everyday luxury into a marketable product. This holiday season, though, SKIMS has managed to turn that promise into a — rather expensive — punchline. 

    Kim Kardashian’s SKIMS recently introduced its 2026 Accessories Advent Calendar, a 12-day collection of “fun surprises” including “hair accessories to keychains and more” for a staggering $148 price tag, which they have since removed from their website and stores following backlash. Contrary to the advertised description, there wasn’t any “more.” Consumers have taken to social media to question what exactly it is that they paid for. One viral TikTok video unboxing the advent calendar accumulated nearly 60 million views and hundreds of response videos. An overarching criticism is that the collection in its entirety seems to offer remarkably little for a price that could cover someone’s entire holiday shopping budget. 

    The internet’s reaction is amusing, but the controversy leads me to question the point at which the perceived value of a brand becomes entirely inflated and detached from the value of its products. 

    The SKIMS calendar is not technically an example of traditional shrinkflation, which occurs when companies reduce a product’s quantity per unit while maintaining prices. Rather, it illustrates the related phenomenon of the premiumization of seemingly ordinary consumer goods. 

    Shrinkflation is a familiar frustration in an economy where consumers are paying more and receiving less. From groceries to household necessities, companies have meticulously found ways to preserve profit margins without necessarily making price increases overtly obvious. But the SKIMS controversy suggests that this logic extends past quantity reduction and that companies do not always need to give consumers less. They simply need to convince customers that an ordinary product is worth considerably more. 

    This is where capitalism’s relationship with consumer identity becomes particularly interesting. In his 1899 book, The Theory of the Leisure Class, economist Thorstein Veblen introduced the concept of “conspicuous consumption,” arguing that people often purchase goods to communicate wealth and social status instead of simple practical utility. The value of an object extends beyond what it does and instead becomes about the message it communicates about the consumer. 

    Veblen’s argument was rooted in the social hierarchies of his time, when extravagant clothing, leisure activities and material possessions distinguished the wealthy from the working class. Yet, over a century later, his theory still feels relevant to an economy increasingly centered around personal branding and social media. The specific objects being marketed may have changed, but the underlying urge to communicate status through consumption remains. 

    SKIMS is an example of this phenomenon because its products derive value from their association with a marketed lifestyle rather than practical function alone. A hair tie is fundamentally a hair tie. But a hair tie bearing the SKIMS logo can be marketed as part of a luxury experience, carrying with it the cultural associations of fame, exclusivity and aspirational femininity. 

    Brands will market a different identity every other week: the “clean” girl, the “cool” girl, the “effortlessly chic” girl. Each aesthetic comes with its own carefully curated shopping list. Want to achieve that clean girl look? Buy a red light therapy mask. Concerned about inflammation around your legs and waist? If you want to be a health and wellness girl, a vibration plate is now essential. Woke up on the wrong side of bed? That’s hardly effortless-chic. Better stock up on a lifetime supply of under eye patches. 

    The joke, of course, is that none of these material things are necessary to being clean, cool, healthy or chic — whatever your definition of that is — but social media marketing presents them as essential components of these idealized identities. The consumer is then purchasing the promise of becoming a particular kind of person. 

    There is, however, a contradiction at the center of this system. The same products that promise exclusivity are often marketed to enormous audiences, which encourages as many consumers as possible to participate in an identity that is supposedly ‘distinctive.’ The impact on brands is that they must continually invent new ways to make ordinary products feel exclusive, whether through limited-edition releases — like a holiday advent calendar — celebrity collaborations or inflated price points. 

    The contradiction extends to the ideal of femininity itself. The supposedly effortless woman requires an extraordinary amount of effort, time and consumption to emulate. Looking as though one has naturally rolled out of bed with glowing skin and a perfectly styled outfit can involve an elaborate rotation of skincare products, beauty treatments, supplements and clothing. The appearance of effortlessness becomes its own expensive project. 

    There is also a hilarious irony in the backlash against the SKIMS calendar. The same social media platforms that encourage consumers to participate in these idealized lifestyles provide a space to criticize the products being sold to achieve them. But even negative attention has commercial value. Viral unboxing videos have introduced the calendar to millions of people who might never have encountered it otherwise. In a consumer economy, buyers ridicule products while simultaneously contributing to the visibility that makes them so desirable to another buyer. 

    Ultimately, this is what makes the SKIMS controversy more significant than a disagreement over the cost of an advent calendar. It demonstrates how effectively capitalism transforms social aspiration into commercial demand. When consumers are encouraged to measure their identities through the things they own, the practical value of a product becomes secondary to the status attached to purchasing it. A company does not necessarily need to sell consumers something they need; they need to convince them that owning it says something about who they are. 

    Reem Nasrallah

    Reem Nasrallah is a member of the Class of 2028 in the School of Industrial and Labor Relations. She is a senior editor for the 144th Editorial Board and was an assistant news editor for the 143rd Editorial Board. She can be reached at rnasrallah@cornellsun.com.

    Read More

    Share.

    Comments are closed.