Steve Hilton speaks with the media after a town hall meeting in San Francisco on July 10, 2026. Hilton suffered the worst defeat for a California Republican gubernatorial candidate in history.

    Steve Hilton speaks with the media after a town hall meeting in San Francisco on July 10, 2026. Hilton suffered the worst defeat for a California Republican gubernatorial candidate in history.

    Benjamin Fanjoy/For the S.F. Chronicle

    Headlines in the last couple of weeks have focused on thunderous Democratic victories nationwide: Senate seats in ruby red territory like Kansas and Mississippi, U.S. House margins so big they overwhelmed gerrymandering in North Carolina, and once-unfathomable statehouse control in places like Texas.

    But the tsunami washed over blue California too.

    Because Democrats so thoroughly control California politics, and because Prop 50 had already tipped the scales in the U.S. House, fewer eyes have been watching the multi-generational wipeout of the state’s Republican power that has played out as the state has steadily counted its vote.

    Article continues below this ad

    Consider the list of milestones. Governor-elect Xavier Becerra, not widely considered a strong candidate, earned just under two-thirds of the vote, and Democrats are on pace to control 68 seats in the 80-member Assembly and 32 in the 40-strong state Senate. All would be records going back to 1930 — when it was Republicans who ran up overwhelming margins.

    So deep was the rout that Republicans came up short in strongholds like Kern County, where voters not only drummed out a long-serving U.S. House member, but also unseated the Republican leader in the state Assembly.

    The Democrats have never had so much power. How did they do so well?

    Article continues below this ad

    A blue state exception

    14 points in Kansas. 15 in South Carolina. 19 in Texas.

    These were the size of the percentage-point swings toward Democrats in U.S. House races in some of the important states that flipped. But with President Donald Trump’s administration plumbing new depths of unpopularity, swings of this magnitude, and even larger, were the rule across the country — particularly in red states. Although Democrats didn’t pick up Senate seats there, voters in Alabama, Kentucky and Indiana swung towards Democrats in House races by a margin of 21 points.

    Paradoxically, Democrats tended to make much more modest gains in blue and traditionally purple states in the North. In Minnesota, Michigan and Maine, where Democrats posted comfortable margins on bluer turf, voters swung 10 points leftward or less. The swing was even smaller in securely Democratic Oregon, at just 5 points.

    Article continues below this ad

    And in sapphire-blue New York, solid Democratic margins this year masked an ominous trend for the party: The state has been getting steadily less blue since the Obama era. Some commentators have theorized that voters in long-Democratic states are tired of the perceived failures of blue-state governance.

    But if that were uniformly the case, California should also have seen a modest blue swing. It didn’t: Voters here moved left by a hefty 17 points.

    Why? One answer lies in what blue state Republicans elsewhere are doing. In just the last ten years, states as blue as Vermont, Massachusetts and Maryland have had Republican governors.

    “When they have won, they’ve done so by presenting different types of candidate than voters associate with the national party,” said Dan Schnur, a former Republican communications strategist.

    Article continues below this ad

    “California Republicans just haven’t been willing to make that adjustment.”

    Latino voters flipped Democratic again — for now

    Perhaps the bigger reason is what the Chronicle and other outlets have been beating the drum about for years now: Latino voters are the swing vote — not just in California, where they are numerous, but across the nation.

    Going into 2026, those voters absolutely loathed what Republicans were doing.

    The record of their equivocation over the last decade is dramatic. Although Hillary Clinton rallied strong majorities of minority voters, including Latinos, against the threat of a xenophobic Trump campaign in 2016, those voters later began to assess Trump’s Republicans more favorably. That came first in a trickle in 2020 and 2022, and then in a flood in 2024. Surveys showed that these voters were not primarily driven by concerns over immigration, but over the economy and affordability.

    Article continues below this ad

    In fact, Latino voters’ behavior may have less to do with ethnic affinity than their other demographic attributes. They are younger, less ideological and more removed from centers of American wealth and power. These otherwise socially moderate voters gravitate towards more economically populist messages.

    And not all of them are Latino: Many, including in the Bay Area, are Asian.

    After turning against Democrats in 2022 and 2024, these kinds of voters snapped even more forcefully against Republicans this year. And because these less ideological voters are so numerous in California, they drove a powerful leftward shift — even in a high-cost blue state where unemployment is high, real wages are flat and economic inequality is extreme.

    “Look, these voters know California is in a bad place,” said Mike Madrid, an anti-Trump Republican strategist who specializes in reaching Latino voters.

    “But they would rather vote for a place with tents and unaffordability and needles on the ground than vote for (Republicans),” whom they associate with contempt for their interests and their ethnic identity, Madrid said.

    As yet, Madrid thinks, no party has yet figured out an enduring populist message they can live up to. He said Democrats continue to focus on the concerns of their coastal, professional-class base, while incorrectly treating Latino voters as an immigration-focused group of victims.

    And Trump’s Republicans, said Madrid, continue to double down on the kind of resentment-driven identitarian nationalism that at best excludes Latinos and at worst vilifies and victimizes them — while doing little to address their core concerns about economic mobility.

    Can the CAGOP regroup?

    One thing that strategists agreed on was that despite Democrats’ almost complete failure to make their case in California in 2026, the state’s Republicans could have done little to fight their fate.

    “(Republican gubernatorial candidate) Steve Hilton could have come up with any message he wanted to… and it wouldn’t have changed the outcome,” said Matt Rexroad, a former Yolo County Republican official and political strategist. “It would have been like trying to surf the other way against a tsunami.”

    What strategists are more divided on was what the CAGOP might do next.

    In theory, Republicans could seek out a coalition of voters who are souring on sclerotic Democratic governance. Those voters aren’t just working class: On the other end of the socioeconomic spectrum, some upscale voters have also demonstrated that they are fed up with the “establishment.”

    For instance, in the Bay Area, a new strain of moderate liberalism, one that is variously aligned with the “YIMBY” or “abundance” movements, preaches the kind of thing that Democrats have rarely run on: deregulation as a tool of spurring growth. Socially progressive representative-elect Scott Wiener stands in for one version of this new politics, as does San Jose’s relatively moderate mayor Matt Mahan.

    GOP strategists weren’t hopeful the party could manage to bring those voters in.

    “The short answer is, of course they can broaden the tent. But will they? The answer is no,” said Madrid. “And every year, they shrink, and get more righteous in losing.”

    A large majority of California Republicans are white, in a state where just a third of residents are — and as Schnur pointed out, Republicans are increasingly leaving the state and not being replaced.

    For those who are left, Trump-aligned nationalism is the “animating characteristic” of their politics, said Madrid. They don’t much want to change.

    Meanwhile, Democrats may be beginning to catch on to Latino voters’ concerns. Some border state Democrats Madrid knows, like Ariz. Sen. Ruben Gallego and Texas Sen.-elect James Talarico, have understood that Latino voters are sick of an economic system that feels distant from and hostile to their aspirations. House candidates with wildly differing social views, like the conservative Bobby Pulido in South Texas and more liberal Randy Villegas in California’s San Joaquin Valley, both routed Republican incumbents by running on an economic message.

    If their brand of politics gains a foothold in places like Kern and Tulare counties, strategists said, even the most conservative Latino voters may have reason to stay loyal to Democrats.

    Some, like Rexroad, the Yolo County strategist, said that the GOP can survive only by tending its own garden: focusing on downballot races in moderate and conservative places, rather than placing its hopes on big-budget statewide contests it has no hope of winning.

    Others suggested that only a Hail Mary could save the Republicans now — in the form of a big celebrity who doesn’t have to spend big to establish their brand, and can define their politics in opposition to Democrats rather than as a Republican. “After all, before there was Schwarzenegger, there was Reagan,” said Rob Stutzman, a Sacramento Republican strategist, referring to California’s two iconic actors-turned-Republican governors.

    “California does this once in a while.”

    Share.

    Comments are closed.