A new bill designed to ensure safe health and social care staffing levels in Northern Ireland has drawn criticism from nursing leaders.
The “landmark” Health and Social Care (Staffing) Bill would make the Department of Health, and Health and Social Care (HSC) services across Northern Ireland, legally responsible for maintaining and monitoring safe staffing levels.
“We do not believe the bill provides the robust legislative framework needed”
Rita Devlin
The bill has the stated aim of strengthening workforce planning and governance to ensure enough appropriately trained staff are available across services for effective and safe care delivery.
If passed, it would make Northern Ireland the third out of four UK countries to have safe staffing legislation. Wales became the first country in Europe to legislate on nurse staffing levels in 2016.
Scotland then followed suit, enacting a national staffing legislation to cover entire NHS and social care system in April 2024.
Conversely, England’s government is yet to introduce any staffing legislation, despite considering it in 2020.
In his announcement to the Northern Ireland Assembly, health minister Robbie Butler called it a “significant step” to creating a more sustainable health and social care system.
He said: “Delivering safe, high-quality care depends on having the right staff, in the right place, at the right time. The challenges facing health and social care are well known.
“This bill represents a significant step forward in strengthening workforce planning and staffing governance across our Health and Social Care system.
Robbie Butler. Image: Northern Ireland Assembly
“It places safe and effective staffing at the heart of strategic decision-making and creates a clear legislative framework to support both those who deliver care and those who rely on it.
“I want to thank everyone who contributed. Their input has made this a stronger bill, and I look forward to continuing that partnership as it progresses through the assembly.”
The origins of the bill date back to 2020, when the Department of Health committed to creating a nurse staffing framework to end unprecedented industrial action from 2019-2020.
It was then delayed until 2022 at the earliest due to Covid-19 and other implementation issues, the Northern Irish Department of Health previously told Nursing Times.
The government confirmed this week it subsequently decided to expand the bill to cover the entire system following “extensive” engagement with and feedback from stakeholders, unions, staff and public consultations.
But the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) said it was “deeply disappointed” with the final proposals, which include a legally bound “staffing objective” and a duty for the Department of Health to report to the assembly on its staffing progress every three years.
Despite being “heavily involved” in the legislation’s early development, the union said it had not been consulted after the bill was drafted.
Professor Rita Devlin, executive director of RCN Northern Ireland, said: “The RCN has worked tirelessly for almost seven years alongside the Department of Health and other trade unions to develop safe staffing legislation for Northern Ireland.
“This legislation was hard won through the determination and courage of nursing staff who took strike action for the first time in the Royal College of Nursing’s history to demand safer care for patients and safer workplaces for staff.
“When we finally had the opportunity to review the bill, it was clear that it fell significantly short of our expectations and the ambitions originally set out for safe staffing.”
Professor Devlin added she did not believe the bill’s proposals in their current form were “robust” enough to deliver safe staffing.
According to the government, the bill would:
- Require the Department of Health, and Health and Social Care trusts, to prepare, publish and implement workforce plans;
- Strengthen accountability and governance through arrangements for monitoring staffing requirements, identifying workforce risks and supporting continuous improvement;
- Provide powers for regulations and statutory guidance to support consistent, evidence-based workforce planning across the Health and Social Care system and to enable workforce planning approaches to evolve in response to changing service needs and emerging evidence;
- Extend consideration of safe and effective staffing across wider Health and Social Care organisations to promote a system-wide approach.
She added: “Safe staffing legislation must be more than a statement of intent.
“It must provide clarity about the accountability and responsibility of both the Department of Health and employers, and ensure there are enough registered nursing staff, with the right skills, in the right place at the right time to deliver safe and effective care.”
The union said it had now formally raised its concerns with the Department of Health, the health minister and members of the assembly’s health committee.
Professor Devlin said the RCN was engaging with “all stakeholders” to seek amendments that would strengthen the bill further and deliver on promises made to Northern Ireland’s nursing staff and patients.
‘‘We are examining the bill closely as we prepare to give evidence to the assembly health committee, but at this stage we believe the bill will need amendment in order to ensure that it is effective and makes a significant impact for the HSC workforce and the delivery of services.”
