The revised proposal, presented on Saturday, 21 November, represents an attempt to reconcile demands from governments seeking to restrain EU expenditure with those arguing that Europe requires significantly greater resources for defence, competitiveness and economic security.
France rejected the proposal shortly after its presentation. The French presidency indicated that the revised framework did not provide an acceptable basis for agreement, with concerns over agricultural funding and the wider distribution of expenditure.
The disagreement comes days before a special European Council meeting on 26–27 November, when EU leaders are expected to attempt to resolve the principal disputes surrounding the next financial framework.
A smaller budget with expanding responsibilities
Costa’s proposal reduces the overall financial package by approximately €40 billion compared with the negotiating framework put forward by the Irish presidency of the Council in October.
Against the Commission’s original proposal, the reduction reaches approximately €180.6 billion, or about 10 per cent, measured in constant prices.
The figures require careful distinction from the nearly €2 trillion initially announced by the Commission in current prices, which incorporate expected inflation during the spending period.
The proposed reduction comes as the Union faces increasing demands for expenditure on defence, industrial development, technological competitiveness and support for Ukraine.
EU Today recently examined how the next European budget has become a contest between established spending commitments and new strategic priorities.
Costa’s revised framework attempts to accommodate those competing demands without requiring member states to accept the full increase originally proposed by the Commission.
According to the European Council president, the proposed financial framework would still increase expenditure in several strategic areas compared with the current budget.
Funding for Horizon Europe, the Union’s principal research and innovation programme, would rise by 57 per cent, while resources devoted to the EU’s international activities would increase by 23 per cent.
However, those comparisons concern the current financial framework, not the larger proposal originally presented for 2028–2034.
Digital taxation returns to the negotiating table
One of the most significant elements of Costa’s proposal concerns the financing of the budget.
The revised plan includes a proposed levy of 3 per cent on specified digital revenues generated by large technology businesses.
The measure would cover activities including online advertising, digital intermediation and the commercial use of user-generated data.
According to the proposal’s reported parameters, the levy would apply to companies with annual digital turnover of at least €50 million within the EU and worldwide turnover exceeding €750 million.
The proposal would therefore concentrate on major digital operators rather than smaller European technology businesses.
The proposed tax revives a longstanding debate over whether large international technology companies contribute an appropriate share of public revenue in the markets where they operate.
It also raises questions about the relationship between EU fiscal policy and trade relations with the United States, where several of the largest digital companies are headquartered.
Unlike national taxes introduced by individual member states, an EU-level revenue mechanism would require agreement on its legal basis and implementation.
France challenges the spending balance
France’s opposition introduces an immediate obstacle to Costa’s attempt to secure a compromise.
Paris has consistently defended the importance of the Common Agricultural Policy, which remains a major component of EU expenditure.
Any substantial reallocation of funding towards defence, competitiveness or new industrial programmes creates potential conflicts with governments seeking to preserve agricultural and regional development support.
At the same time, several net-contributing member states have argued that the Union cannot indefinitely expand its expenditure without reconsidering priorities.
The resulting dispute concerns both the overall size of the budget and the division of financial responsibilities between governments.
The negotiations are also taking place against a difficult economic background. As EU Today reported in its examination of Europe’s fiscal pressures, governments face rising public debt, defence requirements and pressures on domestic services.
A further complication is the repayment of borrowing undertaken through the EU’s post-pandemic recovery programme. Costa’s proposal would retain the repayment timetable while allowing greater flexibility in the pace of capital repayments during the early years.
A decisive week for EU negotiations
The November 26–27 summit will bring together governments with markedly different positions on the financial framework.
Costa is seeking to narrow those differences before further negotiations in December.
Although the next budget will not take effect until January 2028, EU institutions are seeking an early political settlement to allow legislation and spending programmes to be prepared.
The pressure is intensified by elections scheduled in several member states during 2027, which could make subsequent negotiations more difficult.
For the European Union, the immediate question is whether governments can reconcile restrictions on national contributions with commitments to expand European capabilities.
Costa’s proposal establishes a new financial basis for those discussions. France’s rejection demonstrates that agreement on the central spending priorities remains unresolved.
