Share.

36 Comments

  1. Beautiful example of “scientific study prooves that scientific studies conclusions depend on who orders it”

  2. Viablemorgan on

    What rights vary from state to state? I imagine the greatest influence on a state’s score is public attitudes

  3. 55 seems… oddly high, with the laws certain red states are passing specifically to punish trans people

  4. Seems like a reductionist view. LGBTQ+ being lumped as one group with completely aligned goals doesn’t get to the heart of the issue and isn’t great data. If the data sampled those for/against gay rights and split that out from other hot button issues, like competing in sports, gender ops in children, and otherwise took LGBTQ+ letter by letter, the field would likely not look nearly as dire.

  5. VampireInBlack on

    What year was the data from? Utah has taken some huge steps backwards. Even the protections they had before always had exemptions for religious institutions, which hold huge amounts of housing and are among the largest employers

  6. Iowa is NOT a good state. It is as bad as Florida which is a no-travel zone for trans people. Trans Iowans are losing healthcare and our civil rights protections. Both laws signed and the latter starts the first next month.

  7. SmarterThanCornPop on

    Pretty sure the only real differences here are on the T part. Gay rights are ubiquitous.

  8. as a trans person, public acceptance depends alot more on if you are in a rural or urban area than the state, ive lived in florida and PA and Orlando Florida was alot more accepting socially than rural PA

  9. I’m always impressed by Utah in charts like this. If the Mormons manage to be nice, why do all the crazies in the Midwest Bible Belt have to be assholes?

  10. StobbstheTiger on

    I get how the LG and T are relevant for the rights argument, but what differences in rights, laws and freedoms are there for the BQ+?

  11. Rights and public attitude bundled as a single score?
    I’m sorry but that’s a terrible measurement

  12. Ooo, ooo, now overlay “education ranking” and “percentage of population subsisting on welfare”!

  13. flexbuffchest90 on

    The south carolina sandwich with NC and Georgia bread on these types of maps

    Makes me hungry

  14. Wanderingghost12 on

    It seems that Mississippi is continuously at the bottom (or the very top in some cases…) so I think we can just cut that state off. Boost our averages

  15. Every data point I see, says the South is doing really poorly, and it makes me wonder if you can ever truly win or end a civil war. They seem insistent on never recovering and remaining salty forever.

  16. Looking at the details of the scoring, it seems overly indexed on gender identity.

    A country (or state) that declares all homosexual activity to be punishable by death gets a smaller penalty (-100) as a country or state that does not recognize a right to change your gender including non-binary genders (-130 total across five categories). Obviously these things nest, so that a country that gets -100 for making all homosexual activity punishable by death almost certainly does not recognize gender identity and so will get a -230 anyway, but it means that the differences at the margins are magnified.

    The differences in rights between a 30 and 55 are likely much larger than the difference in rights between a 55 and 100.

  17. Frank_the_Mighty on

    The spirit of Massachusetts is the spirit of America,

    The spirit of what’s old and what’s new,

    The spirit of Massachusetts is the spirit of America,

    The spirit of the red white and blue

  18. This map is just a vibe check from subjective sources.
    What does 100 look like, what does 0 look like? What is societal equality a measure of? Two people in the same state can have wildly different experiences based on immeasurable circumstances.

    Equality is an ideal, not a statistic.

  19. RagefireHype on

    The east coast should just move to the west coast so we can all be homies

    But west coast best coast come on over if you don’t want to be around terrible people as frequently.

  20. WhiskyEchoTango on

    Positively surprised at the positions of Utah and Montana. Not surprised by any CSA state except VA, but I’m sure that’s owing to the proximity to DC.

  21. The inclusion of the T confuses me. Let me love who I love is such a different ask than I am something that I’m not.

  22. I am sure this will change radically depending on how you define what that means. Plus, a lot of this is more localized than it is by state. Nice, but a but meaningless.

  23. derliebesmuskel on

    So since the ‘rights, laws, and freedoms’ of LGBTQ+ people’s have in these states are all the same, this really just shows ‘public attitudes’. Why not just label the graph thus?

  24. Wonkas_Willy69 on

    Attitudes aside, what rights are specifically denied in the lower scoring states?