I would like to know your thoughts on this:
—-
I recently watched a video by the YouTuber Jared Henderson: An AI Company Wants to Clone Me
Here's the gist of the video.
– He was approached by an AI cloning startup that wants to create an AI clone of him, so that his clone can interact with his fans/clients (paid sessions) on behalf of him. He refused that, saying that's not authentic.
– The 2nd example he gave was of a woman talking to an AI clone of her dead mother.
– He then proceeded to make the argument that companies that create AI clones are profiting off loneliness, grief and the need for human connection. He says AI clones creates a "para-social" connection i.e. a connection that mimics real life, but it actually isn't real life.
—-
Now coming to my thoughts on this.
I do not disagree with Jared Henderson completely, but I think his arguments was very one sided.
– From the angle of profiting off loneliness and connection, if human clones can be criticized, then so can any dating app be criticized by the same logic. And I have actually found people who have pointed this out
– Going a step further, the relationship between any "celebrity" (here i also include social media personalities) and a fan/viewer/subscriber can also be termed as para-social, because it's not a one-on-one realtionship. So, even when Jared Henderson connects with his audience through his videos or articles, that connection is still para-social, and any money he, or any celebrity makes off it, can be termed as monetzing off para-social relations. So to only blame AI clones, is not fair.
– Finally, coming to AI clones of dead people, he argues that the AI clones are not the real person, and such services are only monetizing other people's grief.
But, people keep pictures and videos of loved ones that are no longer alive, as a way to remember them. We know that photos and videos are not the real person, it's just pixels and bits in a computer. But it still helps people have a memory of someone who's gone.
AI clones only add another layer of personality to a dead person. We know it's not the real person. But it adds an aditional layer of interactivity, beyond pictures and videos. So why bash one technology (AI clones), if other technology (pictures and Videos) are acceptable?
What are your thoughts on AI Avatars/ clones of real humans? Is it a good use of AI Technology, or a form of exploitation?
byu/No_Turnip_1023 inFuturology
9 Comments
No. AI should be primarily used to advance science and technology, not to saturate entertainment, art or corporate profits.
100% exploitation and avenue for causing AI psychosis.
0% useful or morally ok.
Putting a mediocre chatbot in someone’s hands and saying ‘No, really, it’s your dead grandma. Honest.’ is ghoulish and an affront to all moral decency.
There isn’t an argument to be had about it; You may as well be unironically arguing that we should eat the babies of the poor to enact population control.
I personally find the idea of Ai versions of deceased loved ones one of the most repulsive and disrespectful things I’ve ever encountered. Because there’s not even a speck of care, of empathy or even basic human decency in the way the ai version is made, it’s just a machine averaging human behavior from yt videos and vaguely tailoring it to the likeness of the target person. I’d rather have a kid drawing made from memory to remember my father than making an ai version out of him.
dating apps will connect you to another person(eventually). ai dating never ever ever will and will actively prevent you from engaging with other people.
“Relationships” with celebrities that only exist in the head of the fan can already lead to insanity and stalkers. ai clones (frauds) exploitation will lead to mors and worse.
ai clones of dead people will is the worst its worse than those fucking “mediums” who talk to the spirits. they are not he person they arent talking to ghosts they are making shit up to exploit people ony ai clones will probably lead to to increased suicides more guilt more depression. a picture or a video is a captured memory not a program pretending to be a loved one and exploiting you for money
ai is evil
ai lies
ai is fraud
You think online dating is the same as making an AI copy of someone? NGL, that’s just nuts.
“AI clones only add another layer of personality to a dead person.” -> No they don’t. AI clones are an LLM making up shit to please the person interacting with them based on all the written corpus available to humanity.
A picture is a snapshot of a person in their unique settings at a unique moment in time. As such it is a memory.
An AI clone is a text generator trying to masquerade your dead granny for profit and data exploitation. It would be like me taking pictures of your grandma while she was alive. Then reminding you every da that if you want to see your grandma you need to pay me or give me your data. If you don’t, I will burn one of her pictures that you have never seen. If you do give me what I want, I will send you the picture. And against an extra charge, I will also hire a senior sex-worker in Thailand to act as if she is your grandma and talk to you on a phone for $2/Min. How do you feel about such an arrangement? Are you ok with how I chose to “add another layer of personality to a dead person.”?
It seems to me that AI is very much a solution in search of a problem.
Personally, I think this is going to be huge. As we all get older, we also get lonelier. Our partner dies, we get less and less friends and family. Having someone to talk to, that resembles those you know, can be a literal life-saver for the elderly.
Of course there will be many more applications. We all know the sex industry is always first to adopt these technologies, so a sexbot, or even a ‘virtual girl/boyfriend’ will become a huge thing.
Problem is, those bf/gfs will be almost ideal partners, so actual partners will have to compete to even more ideal standards than they have to currently. (this reminds me of the articles stating that most women think 80% of potential male partners are below average, which is both funny and disturbing in its own way).
So yeah, this will definitely happen. Whether that’s a good or a bad thing, is up to how it’s going to be used.