At surface level this makes sense. But thinking a bit more deeply. War has been going on for 4 years. Ukraine should be saturated with AA, while the West should _also_ have increased stockpiles.
This is insane.
U-47 on
SAMPT system production needs to be beefed up.
ukrainianhab on
Ah 2022 Germany is back
ex0e on
It’s kind of crazy that the same “europe is going to be a single county because of Trump” people can turn around and immediately justify independent spending because of the EU. Europe is spending almost the same amount as the US in procurement, yet Ukraine is still lacking.
Its been a year since Trump took office, and the Ukrainian support has slumped precipitously from both the US (obviously) and the EU. Yes the EU has contributed financially to keep Ukraine alive, but where is the material support to win. We have 27 countries plus the UK, and somehow we let fpv drones rule the battlefield against the greatest threat to European security?
Either Russia is or isn’t the great threat, it’s time to decide regardless of TACO tuesday
SpringGreenZ0ne on
The problem is the US. They don’t produce enough, not do they want to.
This is why Macron is boycotting the whole thing even to Storm Shadows (I would trust the UK, but it’s true Farage is just around the corner).
France just reopened a new Renault factory to make drones for Ukraine. If Ukraine’s AA was french, they’d be doing the same.
In theory, even if France falls to LePen or Barbella (whatever their names) they’d keep doing the same, because they want to recover their place as military equipment sellers. In theory as well, they could shift to German’s version if France boycotted.
He’s not wrong at all.
vtsnowdin on
I take such statements with a large grain of salt. The public figures are usually far from the classified real totals.
RisingRapture on
IRIS-T, scale up the production!
LewAshby309 on
Well, it’s not like patriot is the only system.
At first patriots and Gepards were send. Of course this isn’t infinite. Especially the old Gepard system.
Now Ukraine gets continuously new Iris-T systems and SkyRangers.
Sending tons of patriots would be counterproductive. It’s great against expensive missiles but way too costly against Shaheds. More patriots make sense but a wider range of systems make more sense than simply sending more patriots.
What’s doing most damage are drones in combination with missiles in attack waves. What Ukraine needs are many systems like Gepard or Skyranger. They can cost-effective thin out attack waves so the expensive systems like patriot can defend against the more advanced systems.
Only having patriots would mean you need a wishful amount with way too much money for ammunition to just handle one wave.
vimefer on
SAMP-T and Iris-T >> Patriot
fuzzydice_82 on
We started delivery the new Lynx systems, also Skynext systems are on the rise.
Jey3349 on
Patriots are old school. Hopefully the Germans and Ukrainians can develop a newer more capable and cost effective solution.
East-Plankton-3877 on
Are you serious?
Germany, what the hell!? What happened to that new Patriot missile plant you were building *for literally this damn reason*??
uniklyqualifd on
Don’t buy overpriced systems when good enough ones can be built in the EU.
13 Comments
At surface level this makes sense. But thinking a bit more deeply. War has been going on for 4 years. Ukraine should be saturated with AA, while the West should _also_ have increased stockpiles.
This is insane.
SAMPT system production needs to be beefed up.
Ah 2022 Germany is back
It’s kind of crazy that the same “europe is going to be a single county because of Trump” people can turn around and immediately justify independent spending because of the EU. Europe is spending almost the same amount as the US in procurement, yet Ukraine is still lacking.
Its been a year since Trump took office, and the Ukrainian support has slumped precipitously from both the US (obviously) and the EU. Yes the EU has contributed financially to keep Ukraine alive, but where is the material support to win. We have 27 countries plus the UK, and somehow we let fpv drones rule the battlefield against the greatest threat to European security?
Either Russia is or isn’t the great threat, it’s time to decide regardless of TACO tuesday
The problem is the US. They don’t produce enough, not do they want to.
This is why Macron is boycotting the whole thing even to Storm Shadows (I would trust the UK, but it’s true Farage is just around the corner).
France just reopened a new Renault factory to make drones for Ukraine. If Ukraine’s AA was french, they’d be doing the same.
In theory, even if France falls to LePen or Barbella (whatever their names) they’d keep doing the same, because they want to recover their place as military equipment sellers. In theory as well, they could shift to German’s version if France boycotted.
He’s not wrong at all.
I take such statements with a large grain of salt. The public figures are usually far from the classified real totals.
IRIS-T, scale up the production!
Well, it’s not like patriot is the only system.
At first patriots and Gepards were send. Of course this isn’t infinite. Especially the old Gepard system.
Now Ukraine gets continuously new Iris-T systems and SkyRangers.
Sending tons of patriots would be counterproductive. It’s great against expensive missiles but way too costly against Shaheds. More patriots make sense but a wider range of systems make more sense than simply sending more patriots.
What’s doing most damage are drones in combination with missiles in attack waves. What Ukraine needs are many systems like Gepard or Skyranger. They can cost-effective thin out attack waves so the expensive systems like patriot can defend against the more advanced systems.
Only having patriots would mean you need a wishful amount with way too much money for ammunition to just handle one wave.
SAMP-T and Iris-T >> Patriot
We started delivery the new Lynx systems, also Skynext systems are on the rise.
Patriots are old school. Hopefully the Germans and Ukrainians can develop a newer more capable and cost effective solution.
Are you serious?
Germany, what the hell!? What happened to that new Patriot missile plant you were building *for literally this damn reason*??
Don’t buy overpriced systems when good enough ones can be built in the EU.