Expecting people to provide a yes or no response to:
“Should Alberta remain a province of Canada or should the Government of Alberta commence the legal process required under the Canadian Constitution to hold a binding provincial referendum on whether or not Alberta should separate from Canada?”
should be, imho, a complete non-starter.
albanian_rozzer on
Let the people vote. This is a democracy. Right?
Maximum_Error3083 on
30% voting to leave is actually a crazy high number
Leotard_Cohen on
Doesn’t matter what the actual vote result is.
What matters is, will society hold together if things turn violent – how will the police react, how will the feds react, and what will the US do?
Donbas 2013-14 is the separatist template. (And Trump’s too?)
BoosterGoose91 on
Buddy Quebec has been around 30% for well over a generation, grass is always greener. Until it ain’t.
Thereal_Stormm006 on
She stated over & over again that she is a federalist & would vote to stay in Canada. Smith didn’t handle this referendum “poorly”. In fact, she handled it the best way she could.
Expensive_Society_56 on
Anything Smith handles is done poorly.
Unique_Information11 on
30% + apathy is dangerous. Disgruntled people are motivated to vote. People aren’t as motivated to show up to keep the status quo.
JadeLens on
Shocking…
Born_Opening_8808 on
No shit lol
mamajampam on
Well let’s wait and see shall we…
Wild_Pangolin_4772 on
She probably already knows that, and just fulfilling an obligation to the petitioners to shut them up.
Physical_Progress105 on
If the separatists put even just 10% of the energy they use on complaining and redirect to try to improve this country we would be in a much better place.
AloneChapter on
She did what she was told to do. Now the focus can go back to the healthcare scandal
SigmaHouse28 on
Albertans are just a bunch of whiny babies.
Middle-Weight-837 on
Think Brexit – these folks promise you everything and you get misery.
FrankTruth69 on
[ Removed by Reddit ]
Majestic-Cantaloupe4 on
Hey, Alberta! Let’s separate, it will be great! The oil, which already belongs to the province will belong to only Albertans. We’ll probably have to share it with the natives because we’ll have to take over the Federal treaties, since historically, who knows how much of the province will be considered originally theirs, oral records are difficult argue against, and that will be cause for renegotiations. Any company which doesn’t want to ride-out the rough and unpredictable transition will leave. Remember all the headquarters which left Quebec; and they didn’t even go through with their separation. As the highest earning Canadians, we can bear the costs of separating ourselves! It will be so exciting to read about all the things we didn’t anticipate and how no one has a plan but it will be okay, because we will still have our oil which we will share with the natives to get them on side.
Content-Inspector993 on
this is literally so fucking dumb. Have these people thought about the reality of separating? It wouldn’t be pretty
21 Comments
We need the Clarity Act to do its job.
Expecting people to provide a yes or no response to:
“Should Alberta remain a province of Canada or should the Government of Alberta commence the legal process required under the Canadian Constitution to hold a binding provincial referendum on whether or not Alberta should separate from Canada?”
should be, imho, a complete non-starter.
Let the people vote. This is a democracy. Right?
30% voting to leave is actually a crazy high number
Doesn’t matter what the actual vote result is.
What matters is, will society hold together if things turn violent – how will the police react, how will the feds react, and what will the US do?
Donbas 2013-14 is the separatist template. (And Trump’s too?)
Buddy Quebec has been around 30% for well over a generation, grass is always greener. Until it ain’t.
She stated over & over again that she is a federalist & would vote to stay in Canada. Smith didn’t handle this referendum “poorly”. In fact, she handled it the best way she could.
Anything Smith handles is done poorly.
30% + apathy is dangerous. Disgruntled people are motivated to vote. People aren’t as motivated to show up to keep the status quo.
Shocking…
No shit lol
Well let’s wait and see shall we…
She probably already knows that, and just fulfilling an obligation to the petitioners to shut them up.
If the separatists put even just 10% of the energy they use on complaining and redirect to try to improve this country we would be in a much better place.
She did what she was told to do. Now the focus can go back to the healthcare scandal
Albertans are just a bunch of whiny babies.
Think Brexit – these folks promise you everything and you get misery.
[ Removed by Reddit ]
Hey, Alberta! Let’s separate, it will be great! The oil, which already belongs to the province will belong to only Albertans. We’ll probably have to share it with the natives because we’ll have to take over the Federal treaties, since historically, who knows how much of the province will be considered originally theirs, oral records are difficult argue against, and that will be cause for renegotiations. Any company which doesn’t want to ride-out the rough and unpredictable transition will leave. Remember all the headquarters which left Quebec; and they didn’t even go through with their separation. As the highest earning Canadians, we can bear the costs of separating ourselves! It will be so exciting to read about all the things we didn’t anticipate and how no one has a plan but it will be okay, because we will still have our oil which we will share with the natives to get them on side.
this is literally so fucking dumb. Have these people thought about the reality of separating? It wouldn’t be pretty
oh no, another cbc article.
Quebec will separate first.