Proportional voting absolutely, FPTP is such an awful system
Mysterious_Music_677 on
Half of Britons don’t know what a “proportional voting system” is
Disastrous_Fruit1525 on
**Half of Britons(49%) support voting reform….**
That’s as far as I got.
Chillmm8 on
We’ve had polls recently where the party with the most votes ends up with less seats than the party in fourth place. Combined with the frankly silly results that we got at the last election, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to argue in favour of FPTP.
IndependentOpinion44 on
Let’s sort out protecting elections and having election laws with some actual teeth. Then I’ll support PR.
Flat-Struggle-155 on
cool, so now we just need the other half to become literate and learn what a proportional system is.
limeflavoured on
The problem is that most people don’t have a specific system in mind, so it’s easy to deflect the support as not being useful or meaningful.
The AV referendum also gives governments a very good get out clause of “the will of the people…”
I’d personally support either something like Ireland or something like the Scottish Parliament. A purely list based system like, say The Netherlands or Belgium I don’t think is the right answer.
produit1 on
We need a very basic law first. It is still legal to lie to the voter as an MP, you can say whatever you want in terms of false promises and made up facts as a politician.
Make that illegal, a politician should face jail time for not telling the truth in interviews and when in the house of commons. It will be much more difficult for a populist to get to power if that were the case.
As things are currently, a proportional system would only see Putin puppets get voted in.
PiplupSneasel on
At this point, support for reform is gonna make me seek political asylum elsewhere
EleganceOfTheDesert on
Unfortunately the 2 largest parties oppose it, because they know it would only damage them.
lizzywbu on
Voting reform will never happen as long as Labour and Conservative are in power.
AidyCakes on
Our current political duopoly has caused the country to stagnate as neither the Cons or Labour need to offer anything of substance to get elected; they just wait for us to get sick of one party and then let the other one have a go.
FPTP benefits the party donors and not the voting public.
SirJedKingsdown on
All problems with democracy begin and end with the ‘free’ press.
So long as oligarchs have the uncontested capacity to manipulate and deceive the electorate democracy will fail and continue to fail.
ManOnNoMission on
Lib Dems also support proportional voting, if that’s your reason for voting reform at least don’t vote for the Nazi aligned party.
Cabalist_writes on
Had a bit of a panic there as I read that as “half of Britons support voting Reform.” 🤣
terrordactyl1971 on
The champagne socialists and Islington ruling classes are just going to have to realise it’s time for the little man to have his say. They love to look down on the working proletariat as being some sort of sub human underclass not capable of grasping their intellectual arguments….well, the times they are a changing my friends.
anchoredwunderlust on
Gosh I confused voting-reform for voting for Reform
AnotherGreenWorld1 on
I think it would be nice to have a system where I could vote for a party I actually wanted and it actually matter instead of having to vote against someone.
In PR … EVERYONES vote counts towards the government.
My Green vote hasn’t been looked at nationally for decades as it’s wiped out by my local constituency who are in some daft battle of not-Labour/not-Tories.
socialistpancake on
The barrier to proportional representation is that it doesn’t mesh well with the brand of representative democracy we’ve come to enjoy. True PR would result in representatives being assigned after the fact, so you’d be voting for policies, not people.
Personally I like that idea, but people like knowing their representative is local to them.
Commander_Sock66 on
Obviously a load of bollocks. Anytime they do these polls, no one i know has ever been involved with them, so how many people are they actually asking, if any at all? It’s all just to stir up shit, as usual.
Embo1 on
Whatever you believe in politically, we can’t have Farage as PM. He genuinely doesn’t give a shit about this country, and he’s only in it to sell us to the highest bidder and get as rich as possible.
Appropriate-Divide64 on
I downvoted before I realised reform has a little r
digidevil4 on
Im honestly shocked that in this day and age there are still people out there willing to defend FPTP and regurgitate the same nonsense arguments about PR having its own problems. As if we haven’t just had decades of poor government, and no choice to get rid of any of them.
We absolutely need it, but the problem is that governments who can implement it got in under FPTP and so any previous desire for voting reform quickly dissipates.
25 Comments
Proportional voting absolutely, FPTP is such an awful system
Half of Britons don’t know what a “proportional voting system” is
**Half of Britons(49%) support voting reform….**
That’s as far as I got.
We’ve had polls recently where the party with the most votes ends up with less seats than the party in fourth place. Combined with the frankly silly results that we got at the last election, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to argue in favour of FPTP.
Let’s sort out protecting elections and having election laws with some actual teeth. Then I’ll support PR.
cool, so now we just need the other half to become literate and learn what a proportional system is.
The problem is that most people don’t have a specific system in mind, so it’s easy to deflect the support as not being useful or meaningful.
The AV referendum also gives governments a very good get out clause of “the will of the people…”
I’d personally support either something like Ireland or something like the Scottish Parliament. A purely list based system like, say The Netherlands or Belgium I don’t think is the right answer.
We need a very basic law first. It is still legal to lie to the voter as an MP, you can say whatever you want in terms of false promises and made up facts as a politician.
Make that illegal, a politician should face jail time for not telling the truth in interviews and when in the house of commons. It will be much more difficult for a populist to get to power if that were the case.
As things are currently, a proportional system would only see Putin puppets get voted in.
At this point, support for reform is gonna make me seek political asylum elsewhere
Unfortunately the 2 largest parties oppose it, because they know it would only damage them.
Voting reform will never happen as long as Labour and Conservative are in power.
Our current political duopoly has caused the country to stagnate as neither the Cons or Labour need to offer anything of substance to get elected; they just wait for us to get sick of one party and then let the other one have a go.
FPTP benefits the party donors and not the voting public.
All problems with democracy begin and end with the ‘free’ press.
So long as oligarchs have the uncontested capacity to manipulate and deceive the electorate democracy will fail and continue to fail.
Lib Dems also support proportional voting, if that’s your reason for voting reform at least don’t vote for the Nazi aligned party.
Had a bit of a panic there as I read that as “half of Britons support voting Reform.” 🤣
The champagne socialists and Islington ruling classes are just going to have to realise it’s time for the little man to have his say. They love to look down on the working proletariat as being some sort of sub human underclass not capable of grasping their intellectual arguments….well, the times they are a changing my friends.
Gosh I confused voting-reform for voting for Reform
I think it would be nice to have a system where I could vote for a party I actually wanted and it actually matter instead of having to vote against someone.
In PR … EVERYONES vote counts towards the government.
My Green vote hasn’t been looked at nationally for decades as it’s wiped out by my local constituency who are in some daft battle of not-Labour/not-Tories.
The barrier to proportional representation is that it doesn’t mesh well with the brand of representative democracy we’ve come to enjoy. True PR would result in representatives being assigned after the fact, so you’d be voting for policies, not people.
Personally I like that idea, but people like knowing their representative is local to them.
Obviously a load of bollocks. Anytime they do these polls, no one i know has ever been involved with them, so how many people are they actually asking, if any at all? It’s all just to stir up shit, as usual.
Whatever you believe in politically, we can’t have Farage as PM. He genuinely doesn’t give a shit about this country, and he’s only in it to sell us to the highest bidder and get as rich as possible.
I downvoted before I realised reform has a little r
Im honestly shocked that in this day and age there are still people out there willing to defend FPTP and regurgitate the same nonsense arguments about PR having its own problems. As if we haven’t just had decades of poor government, and no choice to get rid of any of them.
[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Approval_voting](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Approval_voting)
[https://electionscience.org/education/approval-voting](https://electionscience.org/education/approval-voting)
We absolutely need it, but the problem is that governments who can implement it got in under FPTP and so any previous desire for voting reform quickly dissipates.