Wha happened in Nepal was something outstanding but something can be said to everyone. To americans, to russians, to iranianians, and etc.
But u need to STUDY that case in order to figure out what happened there.
[deleted] on
[deleted]
Afraid_Frosting_5110 on
Coz unlike the Nepalis, Georgian youth have access to a visa free Europe to find a better future for themselves.
Also Georgians aren’t even half ferocious than the Nepalis(no offense intended, see what they did recently, also read Gorkha history).
So the scale of such a protest will never of the same level as it was in Nepal.
Without such a scale of violence, you can’t overthrow a sticky regime.
Nepali protesters also had this relief that none of its 2 giant neighbors, India and China, would take advantage of this situation. Can Georgia expect the same from Russia???
***Most importantly, when the Nepali army was called in, it supported the protesters instead of the regime.
Can you expect the same from the Georgian army???
Dramatic-Win-6100 on
Let’s imagine Georgia copied want Nepal did, what then?
Who are the Georgian’s going to elect? what path are they going to choose?
The fact of the matter is power, corrupts.
Does Georgia have the institutions and constitution in place to hold those people who the Georgians choose to take their country forward, accountable?
Biohazard-Control-7 on
Because the Georgian opposition (I don’t know why) decided that you should never use violence.
You should stand on the street and bidzina will eventually leave.
So this is how the average encounter between police and protester goes:
I think the Georgian expression that describes it best is “ტრაკი არ აქვთ” 🤔
Futurama_Nerd on
Because we’re giant pussies. Next question.
Helpful-Device290 on
1. Georgia is not Nepal. Nepal has a population of 20 million and is considered a failed state. We moved away from a “failed state” a long time ago. The government has invested billions in the police and state institutions. it’s not like 100,000 people can cause a “revolution.”
2. The GD has a huge number of supporters. The 2024 election wasn’t rigged in the traditional sense, as the opposition claims. It was literally the electric system that the opposition demanded.
3. The opposition is also filled with drug addicts, zonders, former criminals, and people with zero values. Some are even paid by foreign governments, including Russia. There is no unified voice in the opposition.
4. As shitty as the GD might be for certain groups, the vast majority of people still agree that Georgia has no real alternatives.
papu16 on
BC this sub is echo chamber and young generation actually have different vision about country’s future.
Mediocre_Peanut7615 on
Georgian Police forces are lot stronger than Nepalese, much more resources are dedicated to their training, equipment and readiness, both financial and intellectual.
Also, We are lot more soy than Nepalese people. I’d prefer to get of rid the GD in a peaceful manner
_g4n3sh_ on
Stick to the Philippines mate
shalvad on
Because Georgians are wise and don’t want to destroy their country.
BrrZrrKa on
Let see them get out of the mess they drag themselves into first, if everything turns out good maybe we truly have a thing or two to learn from them.
zulcom on
Georgians themselves keep asking the very same question to Russians, Georgia now goes on the same track, so answer soon would be pretty obvious for everyone
sxva-da-sxva on
Georgia is anything but corrupt to the extent that Nepal is. Look at the corruption perceptions index. Georgia is doing better than Bulgaria and Romania, for example. It’s not that bad here. Also, yeah, people can easily emigrate.
Glad_Seat_6287 on
First, why does everyone suddenly think that what happened in Nepal is a success? Only time will tell how things will go.
I’m not Georgian, and I only follow the country on a surface level. But as far as I know, Georgian youth have in fact protested against their government. Because they aren’t building down buildings means they aren’t doing anything?
ZUM809 on
აკონტროლებს მაგ “გულისცემას” სუსი და ზებრების მბრძანებელი. როგორც კი აიწევს ტემპერატურა და ნეპალის საშიშროება გაჩნდება, ესენიც მიიღებენ ზომებს მომენტალურად. მაგარ კონტროლში ვყავართ.
LashaNY on
Georgia has very small population thus its easier for them to buy off enough of the population to keep them safe. Cracks are starting in their own groups so chances in future large protests like one we had last year might be their end.
postpostmetameta on
I believe demographics explain a large part of the difference. Half of Nepal’s population is under 25; it’s a real Zoomer country. As for Georgia – i’m too lazy to look up the exact numbers, but there are not so much young people
FR_FX on
Because the govt is broadly popular
Jarji1234 on
Overthrowing an oppressive government is no guarantee for a better future. Nepal did it, hopefully it works out for them and whoever gets power, overcomes the huge challenges in the country.
As a Georgian seeing Bidzina government failing in numerous areas and being corrupt, as most of the Georgians we want better. I don’t see things becoming better with a random opposition leaders, who don’t even have peoples’ support to herald the opposition protests, coming to power through violence, revolution, “people’s power”, whatever u want to call it.
CherryUnited146 on
Violent revolutions rearly result in desirable outcomes. Just ask goold old friends of Abkhazia, Venezuela
Ok_Gold2097 on
Georgian and Nepal situation isn’t same. Protesting doesn’t always end well. And while I’m against government, I don’t want my country to be demolished and/or people to be injured. We are already small.
NekudSNEK on
because my generation is full of pussies and most of them are all bark and no talk, they’ll follow someone like nancy and talk shit about police beating women and do nothing other than record it and moan on social media when they see it and wonder why nothing ever changes. most of gen z will shut or oppose anyone who brings up subject of being more aggressive, thats what they did last year when group of guys started beating group of titushkas and nobody aired it, even they opposed those actions. we deserve everything we have especially with country being in this colorful revolution retarded people hands.
300 days of bullshit, meanwhile nepal did it in 48 hours.
and as long as these retarded people oppose gun ownership laws and think making gun ownership and legalization of defending yourself will increase criminal rate, even if we change the government, same shit will happen.
MshoAlik on
Why not take Armenia’s example instead ?
UniversalTcell on
Contrary to what a lot of people here think, Georgia doesn’t really have the economic or social conditions for a revolution (not saying there aren’t problems). The ruling party has plenty of support and keeps open lines of communication with the public. The state apparatus in Georgia is pretty strong, especially compared to Nepal.
28 Comments
Looming threat of foreign invasion
Wha happened in Nepal was something outstanding but something can be said to everyone. To americans, to russians, to iranianians, and etc.
But u need to STUDY that case in order to figure out what happened there.
[deleted]
Coz unlike the Nepalis, Georgian youth have access to a visa free Europe to find a better future for themselves.
Also Georgians aren’t even half ferocious than the Nepalis(no offense intended, see what they did recently, also read Gorkha history).
So the scale of such a protest will never of the same level as it was in Nepal.
Without such a scale of violence, you can’t overthrow a sticky regime.
Nepali protesters also had this relief that none of its 2 giant neighbors, India and China, would take advantage of this situation. Can Georgia expect the same from Russia???
***Most importantly, when the Nepali army was called in, it supported the protesters instead of the regime.
Can you expect the same from the Georgian army???
Let’s imagine Georgia copied want Nepal did, what then?
Who are the Georgian’s going to elect? what path are they going to choose?
The fact of the matter is power, corrupts.
Does Georgia have the institutions and constitution in place to hold those people who the Georgians choose to take their country forward, accountable?
Because the Georgian opposition (I don’t know why) decided that you should never use violence.
You should stand on the street and bidzina will eventually leave.
So this is how the average encounter between police and protester goes:
https://i.redd.it/05vqm4uwliqf1.gif
Why should we? If we want change just vote for it
I think the Georgian expression that describes it best is “ტრაკი არ აქვთ” 🤔
Because we’re giant pussies. Next question.
1. Georgia is not Nepal. Nepal has a population of 20 million and is considered a failed state. We moved away from a “failed state” a long time ago. The government has invested billions in the police and state institutions. it’s not like 100,000 people can cause a “revolution.”
2. The GD has a huge number of supporters. The 2024 election wasn’t rigged in the traditional sense, as the opposition claims. It was literally the electric system that the opposition demanded.
3. The opposition is also filled with drug addicts, zonders, former criminals, and people with zero values. Some are even paid by foreign governments, including Russia. There is no unified voice in the opposition.
4. As shitty as the GD might be for certain groups, the vast majority of people still agree that Georgia has no real alternatives.
BC this sub is echo chamber and young generation actually have different vision about country’s future.
Georgian Police forces are lot stronger than Nepalese, much more resources are dedicated to their training, equipment and readiness, both financial and intellectual.
Also, We are lot more soy than Nepalese people. I’d prefer to get of rid the GD in a peaceful manner
Stick to the Philippines mate
Because Georgians are wise and don’t want to destroy their country.
Let see them get out of the mess they drag themselves into first, if everything turns out good maybe we truly have a thing or two to learn from them.
Georgians themselves keep asking the very same question to Russians, Georgia now goes on the same track, so answer soon would be pretty obvious for everyone
Georgia is anything but corrupt to the extent that Nepal is. Look at the corruption perceptions index. Georgia is doing better than Bulgaria and Romania, for example. It’s not that bad here. Also, yeah, people can easily emigrate.
First, why does everyone suddenly think that what happened in Nepal is a success? Only time will tell how things will go.
I’m not Georgian, and I only follow the country on a surface level. But as far as I know, Georgian youth have in fact protested against their government. Because they aren’t building down buildings means they aren’t doing anything?
აკონტროლებს მაგ “გულისცემას” სუსი და ზებრების მბრძანებელი. როგორც კი აიწევს ტემპერატურა და ნეპალის საშიშროება გაჩნდება, ესენიც მიიღებენ ზომებს მომენტალურად. მაგარ კონტროლში ვყავართ.
Georgia has very small population thus its easier for them to buy off enough of the population to keep them safe. Cracks are starting in their own groups so chances in future large protests like one we had last year might be their end.
I believe demographics explain a large part of the difference. Half of Nepal’s population is under 25; it’s a real Zoomer country. As for Georgia – i’m too lazy to look up the exact numbers, but there are not so much young people
Because the govt is broadly popular
Overthrowing an oppressive government is no guarantee for a better future. Nepal did it, hopefully it works out for them and whoever gets power, overcomes the huge challenges in the country.
As a Georgian seeing Bidzina government failing in numerous areas and being corrupt, as most of the Georgians we want better. I don’t see things becoming better with a random opposition leaders, who don’t even have peoples’ support to herald the opposition protests, coming to power through violence, revolution, “people’s power”, whatever u want to call it.
Violent revolutions rearly result in desirable outcomes. Just ask goold old friends of Abkhazia, Venezuela
Georgian and Nepal situation isn’t same. Protesting doesn’t always end well. And while I’m against government, I don’t want my country to be demolished and/or people to be injured. We are already small.
because my generation is full of pussies and most of them are all bark and no talk, they’ll follow someone like nancy and talk shit about police beating women and do nothing other than record it and moan on social media when they see it and wonder why nothing ever changes. most of gen z will shut or oppose anyone who brings up subject of being more aggressive, thats what they did last year when group of guys started beating group of titushkas and nobody aired it, even they opposed those actions. we deserve everything we have especially with country being in this colorful revolution retarded people hands.
300 days of bullshit, meanwhile nepal did it in 48 hours.
and as long as these retarded people oppose gun ownership laws and think making gun ownership and legalization of defending yourself will increase criminal rate, even if we change the government, same shit will happen.
Why not take Armenia’s example instead ?
Contrary to what a lot of people here think, Georgia doesn’t really have the economic or social conditions for a revolution (not saying there aren’t problems). The ruling party has plenty of support and keeps open lines of communication with the public. The state apparatus in Georgia is pretty strong, especially compared to Nepal.