I thought every kid in private school was going to flood into the state system and cripple it though??
Cyanopicacooki on
It’s not a tax hike, it’s closing a loophole – the first of many that need to be sewn up.
jenny_905 on
But the British media spent months repeatedly arguing that this would devastate private schools, they would all close and all the pwecious pupils would be forced to attend state school with commoners.
How can this be?
wkavinsky on
No, you don’t say that companies pretending to be charities while having a shit ton of money might have misrepresented the effects?
Gentle_Snail on
>Some had warned the policy would force students out of private school and into the state system, and whilst this has happened to an extent, councils in March said there had been “no obvious impact” on applications for state sector places.
Euclid_Interloper on
You mean, people with lots of money, actually could afford to pay after all?
What happened to all those struggling working class families, on measly six-figure salaries, who were going to go bankrupt?
rustyb42 on
I thought the rich were all going to Dubai because of this?
mcrmittens on
This is the second* positive Labour story I’ve heard today – what’s happening? Something is seriously afoot! (Or maybe they’ve *finally* hired a PR team?)
*The other being Starmer has already completely smashed Johnson’s prior investment in levelling up the North
Good! That’s more money to spend on state secondary school kids.
Jurassic_Bun on
It’s October why are we referencing things councils said in March? That was 7 months ago.
Rough_Champion7852 on
But how much VAT was reclaimed by the schools for capital / building projects.
The analysis of the total VAT reclaimed the schools, the VAT netted by the govt and the (if any) reduction in private school places (with subsequent state school increase) at the end of the government will be interesting.
If labour do not secure a second term, I can see labour may have just given a tax rebate to the schools at a net loss to the government.
MoveOutside3053 on
Weird, because I scores of articles over several months about how it would bring about the apocalypse.
sheslikebutter on
I thought every kid in private school was going to instantly leave because paying out 10k was affordable but 12k was insanely high
CountyJazzlike3628 on
Dumb comments on here. It’s based on numbers since January.
1. People cant move school mid-year
2. Parents will try not to move their kids if the children are one year away from GCSE or A Level
3. Then they will transfer to state sector
4. More people will go towards State sector over time/in medium term
Finally this policy was main cause the private school my kids went to closed its doors forever after close on 200 years of operations, wiping thr legacy of their youth off the planet.
So fu k Labour for this policy…class warfare and nothing else They have never changed
JamesZ650 on
So all the scaremongers from the mail, telegraph etc were all totally wrong. What a surprise.
IgneousJam on
But, but … we were told that little Tarquin would have to go to ordinary school with the plebs …
Turns out that the rich have plenty of money, so I say keep squeezing
Loreki on
Good. Buying advantage for your kids ought to be as expensive as possible.
mynameisgill on
Private schools were crying bloody murder, but still increased fees by 14%, on top of the additional VAT?
No_Conversation_3366 on
Reeves level critical thinking im this thread…sigh
Astriania on
Where are all the conservative commentators who were saying it was a bad move, wouldn’t raise any money and just push kids into the overstretched state sector now?
Desperate_Caramel_10 on
Turns out the wealthy will make up any old lies to avoid paying their fair share.
jtthom on
The rates that private school fees have been rising in recent years, the 20% VAT is nothing
Altruistic_Leg_964 on
In what way are they more influencial? How does this influence manifest itself? What point are you making here?
Do you really think that these people have the capacity to fix the state system?
23 Comments
I thought every kid in private school was going to flood into the state system and cripple it though??
It’s not a tax hike, it’s closing a loophole – the first of many that need to be sewn up.
But the British media spent months repeatedly arguing that this would devastate private schools, they would all close and all the pwecious pupils would be forced to attend state school with commoners.
How can this be?
No, you don’t say that companies pretending to be charities while having a shit ton of money might have misrepresented the effects?
>Some had warned the policy would force students out of private school and into the state system, and whilst this has happened to an extent, councils in March said there had been “no obvious impact” on applications for state sector places.
You mean, people with lots of money, actually could afford to pay after all?
What happened to all those struggling working class families, on measly six-figure salaries, who were going to go bankrupt?
I thought the rich were all going to Dubai because of this?
This is the second* positive Labour story I’ve heard today – what’s happening? Something is seriously afoot! (Or maybe they’ve *finally* hired a PR team?)
*The other being Starmer has already completely smashed Johnson’s prior investment in levelling up the North
[https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2025/10/exclusive-starmer-outspends-johnson-on-levelling-up-in-first-year](https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2025/10/exclusive-starmer-outspends-johnson-on-levelling-up-in-first-year)
Good! That’s more money to spend on state secondary school kids.
It’s October why are we referencing things councils said in March? That was 7 months ago.
But how much VAT was reclaimed by the schools for capital / building projects.
The analysis of the total VAT reclaimed the schools, the VAT netted by the govt and the (if any) reduction in private school places (with subsequent state school increase) at the end of the government will be interesting.
If labour do not secure a second term, I can see labour may have just given a tax rebate to the schools at a net loss to the government.
Weird, because I scores of articles over several months about how it would bring about the apocalypse.
I thought every kid in private school was going to instantly leave because paying out 10k was affordable but 12k was insanely high
Dumb comments on here. It’s based on numbers since January.
1. People cant move school mid-year
2. Parents will try not to move their kids if the children are one year away from GCSE or A Level
3. Then they will transfer to state sector
4. More people will go towards State sector over time/in medium term
Finally this policy was main cause the private school my kids went to closed its doors forever after close on 200 years of operations, wiping thr legacy of their youth off the planet.
So fu k Labour for this policy…class warfare and nothing else They have never changed
So all the scaremongers from the mail, telegraph etc were all totally wrong. What a surprise.
But, but … we were told that little Tarquin would have to go to ordinary school with the plebs …
Turns out that the rich have plenty of money, so I say keep squeezing
Good. Buying advantage for your kids ought to be as expensive as possible.
Private schools were crying bloody murder, but still increased fees by 14%, on top of the additional VAT?
Reeves level critical thinking im this thread…sigh
Where are all the conservative commentators who were saying it was a bad move, wouldn’t raise any money and just push kids into the overstretched state sector now?
Turns out the wealthy will make up any old lies to avoid paying their fair share.
The rates that private school fees have been rising in recent years, the 20% VAT is nothing
In what way are they more influencial? How does this influence manifest itself? What point are you making here?
Do you really think that these people have the capacity to fix the state system?