WTF did Fungus ever do to anyone? Guy just wants to enjoy his flies.
Pissonurchips on
We should just ban the people that are making the complaints from the libraries.
Extra-End-764 on
Fungus is a classic , taught me everything I know about lurking
CloneOfKarl on
>A public library in Essex removed McKee’s Three Monsters after a customer complained it included “divisive language”.
>The particular section was: ”’Clear off,” shouted the second monster. ”We don’t want any funny foreigner types here.”’
I’ve never read this, but from what I can gather the point of it is that the two original monsters start off by being rude to the third, but then come to learn the error of their ways.
From the Amazon page:
>The new yellow monster arrived on the island with an intriguing offer: “Let me have a tiny bit of land for myself and I will clear away your rocks, level your ground, and tidy up your jungle.” The very lazy red and blue monsters may not like the strange “funny foreigner type” but how can they refuse especially when they had not the faintest intention of holding up their end of the bargain? How yellow monster succeeds in forcing the two monsters to live up to their promise, while building himself a lush island paradise, **makes for a remarkable modern fable of sharing and acceptance**.
I’d wager that someone seems to have read this line and taken it out of context, just to pretend to feel offended, whilst missing (or intentionally ignoring) the overall message of the story.
Perhaps I’m wrong, but that’s what it seems to be (without actually reading it, which I’m not going to).
Jonography on
>A spokesperson for the Department for Culture, Media and Sport said: “Freedom of speech is one of the core values that defines our society and we expect library collections to represent a variety of perspectives and topics.”
Freedom of speech is important as long as it’s the kind of thing a vocal minority like.
Thousandgoudianfinch on
Having read Verne’s five weeks in a balloon it does use heavy-handed racial stereotypes and frequent usage of various slurs, however it is made a point that only the uneducated servant character calls them thus, whilst the educated hunter and scientist do not. Furthermore the protagonist makes a major point that though Africa is savage and wild it like Europe will be the next seat of Civillisation, just as Asia once was but is no longer and as Europe is but will not be so forever- and so Verne’s book is actually fairly progressive despite the copious amounts of Victorian racism.
One_Reality_5600 on
One fucking complaint, the library should have told them to fuck off.
boomerangchampion on
>”As we make clear in our guidance, we are committed to opposing censorship unless there is a specific risk that providing access to a particular book would break the law or incite hatred or violence.”
No wonder racial tensions are so high, Jules Verne has had that N-bomb sitting around on shelves since the 1860s. It was a hard struggle reading that story about an eccentric in a hot air balloon but somehow I resisted the allure of radicalisation.
Don’t even get me started on Fungus the Bigotman
NahYeahThatsCool on
Cool, can we get a bunch of religious texts pulled as well, then?
Ambersfruityhobbies on
There are people in decision-making positions who really should not be making decisions.
antbaby_machetesquad on
This is the kind of crap that happens when as a society we decided that someone being offended actually matters.
To paraphrase Stephen Fry, ‘you’re offended by that. Well, so fucking what.
spacesentinel1 on
My parents bought me Fungus when I was a kid I’m 56 now and still have it
CNash85 on
For a second there I thought that it was going to be something like what’s happening in the US, where libraries are [being targeted](https://www.pbs.org/newshour/arts/attempts-to-ban-books-are-at-an-all-time-high-these-librarians-are-fighting-back) by right-wing fringe groups for stocking anything to do with LGBTQ+ people or anything they deem to be containing “critical race theory”. Some librarians fight back, only to be shut down when the “concerned parents” get onto local councils and convince them to de-fund the library.
But no, this is the UK, so it’s yet more “political correctness gone mad” bollocks imported straight from the 1980s, dusted off, given a shiny new label (“woke”) and played out once more for the entertainment of people who really couldn’t give a shit what public libraries have on their shelves in the first place.
Spamgrenade on
A spokesperson for the Department for Culture, Media and Sport said: “Freedom of speech is one of the core values that defines our society and we expect library collections to represent a variety of perspectives and topics.”
Five Weeks in a Balloon was removed by Coventry Library Services after a customer complained about its ‘inappropriate and racist’ language.
An internal email read: “[The customer] says it refers to ‘beastly n*****’s and other such terms.”
A public library in Essex removed McKee’s Three Monsters after a customer complained it included “divisive language”.
The particular section was: ”’Clear off,” shouted the second monster. ”We don’t want any funny foreigner types here.”’
I wonder what perspectives and topics are being represented here?
rainator on
The more fascinating news is that there are still public libraries open somewhere.
15 Comments
WTF did Fungus ever do to anyone? Guy just wants to enjoy his flies.
We should just ban the people that are making the complaints from the libraries.
Fungus is a classic , taught me everything I know about lurking
>A public library in Essex removed McKee’s Three Monsters after a customer complained it included “divisive language”.
>The particular section was: ”’Clear off,” shouted the second monster. ”We don’t want any funny foreigner types here.”’
I’ve never read this, but from what I can gather the point of it is that the two original monsters start off by being rude to the third, but then come to learn the error of their ways.
From the Amazon page:
>The new yellow monster arrived on the island with an intriguing offer: “Let me have a tiny bit of land for myself and I will clear away your rocks, level your ground, and tidy up your jungle.” The very lazy red and blue monsters may not like the strange “funny foreigner type” but how can they refuse especially when they had not the faintest intention of holding up their end of the bargain? How yellow monster succeeds in forcing the two monsters to live up to their promise, while building himself a lush island paradise, **makes for a remarkable modern fable of sharing and acceptance**.
I’d wager that someone seems to have read this line and taken it out of context, just to pretend to feel offended, whilst missing (or intentionally ignoring) the overall message of the story.
Perhaps I’m wrong, but that’s what it seems to be (without actually reading it, which I’m not going to).
>A spokesperson for the Department for Culture, Media and Sport said: “Freedom of speech is one of the core values that defines our society and we expect library collections to represent a variety of perspectives and topics.”
Freedom of speech is important as long as it’s the kind of thing a vocal minority like.
Having read Verne’s five weeks in a balloon it does use heavy-handed racial stereotypes and frequent usage of various slurs, however it is made a point that only the uneducated servant character calls them thus, whilst the educated hunter and scientist do not. Furthermore the protagonist makes a major point that though Africa is savage and wild it like Europe will be the next seat of Civillisation, just as Asia once was but is no longer and as Europe is but will not be so forever- and so Verne’s book is actually fairly progressive despite the copious amounts of Victorian racism.
One fucking complaint, the library should have told them to fuck off.
>”As we make clear in our guidance, we are committed to opposing censorship unless there is a specific risk that providing access to a particular book would break the law or incite hatred or violence.”
No wonder racial tensions are so high, Jules Verne has had that N-bomb sitting around on shelves since the 1860s. It was a hard struggle reading that story about an eccentric in a hot air balloon but somehow I resisted the allure of radicalisation.
Don’t even get me started on Fungus the Bigotman
Cool, can we get a bunch of religious texts pulled as well, then?
There are people in decision-making positions who really should not be making decisions.
This is the kind of crap that happens when as a society we decided that someone being offended actually matters.
To paraphrase Stephen Fry, ‘you’re offended by that. Well, so fucking what.
My parents bought me Fungus when I was a kid I’m 56 now and still have it
For a second there I thought that it was going to be something like what’s happening in the US, where libraries are [being targeted](https://www.pbs.org/newshour/arts/attempts-to-ban-books-are-at-an-all-time-high-these-librarians-are-fighting-back) by right-wing fringe groups for stocking anything to do with LGBTQ+ people or anything they deem to be containing “critical race theory”. Some librarians fight back, only to be shut down when the “concerned parents” get onto local councils and convince them to de-fund the library.
But no, this is the UK, so it’s yet more “political correctness gone mad” bollocks imported straight from the 1980s, dusted off, given a shiny new label (“woke”) and played out once more for the entertainment of people who really couldn’t give a shit what public libraries have on their shelves in the first place.
A spokesperson for the Department for Culture, Media and Sport said: “Freedom of speech is one of the core values that defines our society and we expect library collections to represent a variety of perspectives and topics.”
Five Weeks in a Balloon was removed by Coventry Library Services after a customer complained about its ‘inappropriate and racist’ language.
An internal email read: “[The customer] says it refers to ‘beastly n*****’s and other such terms.”
A public library in Essex removed McKee’s Three Monsters after a customer complained it included “divisive language”.
The particular section was: ”’Clear off,” shouted the second monster. ”We don’t want any funny foreigner types here.”’
I wonder what perspectives and topics are being represented here?
The more fascinating news is that there are still public libraries open somewhere.