This is the bill in question. I’d be interested to see the Attorney General’s assessment of it. I don’t think some of it would be legal under EU law.
kil28 on
Trade is, of course, an EU competency, so the bill isn’t something the Irish government can actually enact.
I’m sick of politicians wasting Dáil time with this rubbish, can they actually work towards something productive for once.
I suppose it’s a great sound bite for them though. PPB sticking it up to Israel only to be stopped in their tracks by evil FFG. It will go down great with their social media followers who never bother their arse to vote
asdrunkasdrunkcanbe on
For the same reason that Brexit couldn’t have a special trade deal for Northern Ireland and that Trump couldn’t do trade deals directly with Germany and France, decisions relating to trade and sanction on states outside of the EU are the sole competency of EU bodies.
Ireland, as an EU state, is not legally permitted to sanction other countries unilaterally.
This bill was performative nonsense. It could never be made law.
Serious_Bowler_8171 on
They should be ashamed
Dramatic-Set8761 on
Pity we dont have Susan Collins from Maine expressing her concern. /s
Banania2020 on

Another strong message from our Government 🙄
Yasimear on
Traitors.
PoppedCork on
Talking out of both sides of their mouths
explosiveshits7195 on
For those about to shit all over this the government are playing a bigger game, same as all the other broadly pro-palestine governments in Europe. They putting all their efforts behind a pan EU sanction rather than blow all their political capital on a poorly fleshed out singular sanction that will barely dent Israeli income and land us as a reactive outlier on the international stage. This is actual statecraft, not a debate in a pub.
I’m very happy to shit on this government on most issues but in this case I wont, PbP are just doing what they always do, putting forward bullshit symbolic bills that they know dont work when scrutinized while trying to claim the government are do nothing Zionists.
Fit_Accountant_4767 on
Simon Harris posted this on Twitter this morning less than 24 hours after the vote
Remember some of the Death threats the Taniste recieved came from Israel
Ok-Call-4805 on
The kidnapping of the president’s sister by what are basically pirates should be enough to sever any ties with Israel. This needs to be treated as a far bigger deal.
Entire-Gas-7651 on
Genuinely what is the point in sovereignty if we can’t pass OTB or bills like this?
cacamilis22 on
Why aren’t Michael Martin and Helen mcentee on that list?
CaptainNuge on
No abstensions? 35 people just didn’t show up for work. Why are these people getting paid, exactly?
2europints on
I understand this is essentially a publicity stunt by certain parties and likely has no capability of being legally binding. That being said, do they not understand that forcing a no vote by the sitting government does nothing but provide Israel with propaganda? Stupid move, not going to gain the voters they are aiming for.
We already know the government isn’t doing enough. This doesn’t help.
Tommybhoy080 on
The Blueshirts, surprise surprise
TheSwedeIrishman on
Handy little party breakdown from a Mozilla addon I’m developing:
26 Comments
It’s very much feels like a lot of dirt is had on a lot of people.
Sanctions when ?
No no, strong condemnations should do it. Good work guys
/S to clarify
Can we get a list of tds who voted against?
Kidnap the presidents sister in international waters and hold her hostage and literally nothing but a tut tut.
I’m sure Mehole will offer a stern rebuke to Israel in his next media appearance instead
Talk about being gaslit by a Taoiseach
https://data.oireachtas.ie/ie/oireachtas/bill/2025/73/eng/initiated/b7325d.pdf
This is the bill in question. I’d be interested to see the Attorney General’s assessment of it. I don’t think some of it would be legal under EU law.
Trade is, of course, an EU competency, so the bill isn’t something the Irish government can actually enact.
I’m sick of politicians wasting Dáil time with this rubbish, can they actually work towards something productive for once.
I suppose it’s a great sound bite for them though. PPB sticking it up to Israel only to be stopped in their tracks by evil FFG. It will go down great with their social media followers who never bother their arse to vote
For the same reason that Brexit couldn’t have a special trade deal for Northern Ireland and that Trump couldn’t do trade deals directly with Germany and France, decisions relating to trade and sanction on states outside of the EU are the sole competency of EU bodies.
Ireland, as an EU state, is not legally permitted to sanction other countries unilaterally.
This bill was performative nonsense. It could never be made law.
They should be ashamed
Pity we dont have Susan Collins from Maine expressing her concern. /s

Another strong message from our Government 🙄
Traitors.
Talking out of both sides of their mouths
For those about to shit all over this the government are playing a bigger game, same as all the other broadly pro-palestine governments in Europe. They putting all their efforts behind a pan EU sanction rather than blow all their political capital on a poorly fleshed out singular sanction that will barely dent Israeli income and land us as a reactive outlier on the international stage. This is actual statecraft, not a debate in a pub.
I’m very happy to shit on this government on most issues but in this case I wont, PbP are just doing what they always do, putting forward bullshit symbolic bills that they know dont work when scrutinized while trying to claim the government are do nothing Zionists.
Simon Harris posted this on Twitter this morning less than 24 hours after the vote
https://preview.redd.it/appuffpl7h2h1.png?width=1084&format=png&auto=webp&s=32cef1409970a7f5d80f18fa4de13e76c1900ec2
Remember some of the Death threats the Taniste recieved came from Israel
The kidnapping of the president’s sister by what are basically pirates should be enough to sever any ties with Israel. This needs to be treated as a far bigger deal.
Genuinely what is the point in sovereignty if we can’t pass OTB or bills like this?
Why aren’t Michael Martin and Helen mcentee on that list?
No abstensions? 35 people just didn’t show up for work. Why are these people getting paid, exactly?
I understand this is essentially a publicity stunt by certain parties and likely has no capability of being legally binding. That being said, do they not understand that forcing a no vote by the sitting government does nothing but provide Israel with propaganda? Stupid move, not going to gain the voters they are aiming for.
We already know the government isn’t doing enough. This doesn’t help.
The Blueshirts, surprise surprise
Handy little party breakdown from a Mozilla addon I’m developing:
https://i.imgur.com/ak9i2ZG.png
Needs to be done on an EU level, but there are far too many cowards running EU member governments.

Hope y’all remember this when that weasel Harris is spouting on about his support for Palestine