Is the official government line still “there’s no connection between high taxes and the black market”??
JASHIKO_ on
They taxed everyone so hard they created a blackmarket… Who’d have ever guessed….
I’d expect to see more of this stuff happening as the price of everything goes through the roof.
blenders_pride666 on
Our government is so idiotic its unbelievable, the tobacco wars and smuggling is something they have directly created – nobody else to blame. The taxes on smoking far outweigh the cost that smokers have on our public healthcare system. They also completely fucked up with vapes as well, I used to be able to easily buy nicotine and choose my own strengths, now all you can easily get is a ridiculously strong and overpriced disposable. Watch the same thing start happening with alcohol soon….
Whitemeat123 on
Its unfortunate that there’s still that 20% missing out
BlooBloo82 on
No one saw this coming, unprecedented, usually prohibition works flawlessly
Roulette-Adventures on
I gave up when smokes got to about $35 a packet, that was two years ago. Tried nicotine aids and patches – fucking useless. Went cold turkey and it worked a treat.
I never could find a source for cheap smokes, otherwise I might have kept smoking.
jianh1989 on
It’s cheaper. Who can you blame?
babycynic on
Banning vapes and overtaxing cigarettes is going to go down as one of the dumbest public health decisions in history, I can’t believe that after years of progress with reducing the smoking rate that it’s going up again. It’s making it so much easier for kids to start smoking or vaping cos no one gives a shit about selling to teens anymore because it’s illegal already, it’s just a fucked situation and now the government won’t even have tax dollars to help cover the cost of all of the future health issues.
Bigthunderrumblefish on
Congratulations to Tobacco for winning the war on Tobacco
Cheap-Desk-4778 on
*Just* 80% …?
Creative-Leg2607 on
Good on us
welcomefinside on
This checks out, of all of the people I know who smokes only one of them gets the legit durries
xarenox on
Why are we typing percentage as ‘pc’ instead of %
RedDeer505 on
They should try prohibition next.
Oh, sorry, I thought the brief was for things that don’t work. My mistake.
tremulous_heart_req on
This is fucking insanity.
Utter failure of governance.
Oz-jim1 on
The greedy idiots and puppets in government will never learn to cut down on their unchecked spendings instead of taxing the population to death.
People will find a way to survive the high taxation.
Most-Pie2681 on
Up next sky is blue.
Rev-Dr-Slimeass on
I moved here from New Zealand a month ago, and it has been absolutely mindblowing how much this country smells like cigarettes. NZ has a ton of vapers, but that doesn’t really smell. There are smokers absolutely everywhere here and it stinks.
DecidedUser on
Coming from a bartender I would estimate high 90%, I do not really ever see legal tobacco anywhere. Our tobacco vending machine is effectively never used. Doesn’t matter if they are a tourist who barely speaks english or a local.
abbellire70 on
We know ! we smell it.
kafka99 on
Just lower the taxes, FFS
ceesie12 on
I still have no idea where to get cheap smokes.
Sick of paying $100+ for a pouch lmao.
Talos2005 on
Good fuck this overtaxing government.
iball1984 on
Another scary number – Australians are using 40% more nicotine than in 2017.
That obviously includes vaping, but is yet another example of the complete and total failure of government policy
Jealous-Hedgehog-734 on
There’s five illegal cigarette vendors within walking distance of my local police station and they are not trying to hide their trade.
We have to reset the price of legal cigarettes slightly lower than the smuggled ones to drive them out.
SpitefulRedditScum on
I moved from Brisbane to Sydney this year and haven’t found a black market here yet. Seems way more locked down in comparison to Brisbane.
It’s currently $38 for a the cheapest pack of 20’s at colesworth
ScissorNightRam on
Is it true that every package of Manchester cigs is illegal?
I see the empty packs as gutter rubbish all the time, and someone once told me there is actually no way to buy them legit
Separate-Law-435 on
If only we had lessons in history about trying to tax/prohibit something to the wahzoo.
Who would have thought/s
bruhhhhhhhhhhhh_h on
I wonder / hope they accounted for the increasing quantity of nicotine in the “illegal” / disposable vapes.
From a brief skim – cigarettes (blues) are 12-16 mg, reds edging up a bit over 20mg.
The maximum non prescription is 20mg.
Many of the disposables are hitting “5%” or 50mg, I’m aware of many being 10% 0r 100mg.
It’s not like for like and there are other factors, but raw number wise vapes, certainly, have more nicotine. Does this represent more people ingesting more tobacco products and vapes at what kind of ratio ?
I would say I’ve seen more people vaping but a shitload less pumping durries. My local bottle store just dropped selling them completely.
IMHO banning the “actual” OG vape stores with reusable, better made devices and consumable elements and at least a kind of rudimentary validation in so far as known “brands”, flavour and such – just lead to an onslaught of e-waste, cheeky battery juice mixes, poor quality electronics and the commercial viability of using rechargeable li-ion batteries in a disposable device.
Along with a raft of other chaos, fire bombings and rogue activity that was unprecedented outside of the repeated examples globally throughout previous decades, the current time and likely core elements of human behaviour.
plutoforprez on
Thought they were too expensive to buy at the $25 mark so never did. I smoke more now than I do back then, $10 is too good not to.
Conan3121 on
A massive failure of government and law enforcement.
Einnnnnnnnnnnn on
And vascular disease related amputations have plummeted.
The tax and the plain packaging are good policies.
They will be ideal when the tax haul from tobacco is zero.
Now, arrest the illegal tobacco shops and importers and fine the Bejeezus out of them.
SJammie on
This was always going to happen. I hate smoking, but this was a very foreseeable outcome. Smokers are addicts, eventually they’ll have to find the hit in a way they can afford.
myztry on
The Government’s border control is an absolute joke when you understand just what a massive volume of material that 80% of the tobacco market is. We don’t even share land borders with any other nation so there’s no hope of keeping the real nasty stuff out at this level of incompetence.
SilverBBear on
I quit from $4 to $5 a pack I though – thats awesome just jack up the price and everyone will quit. Yeh Nah. There was a limit to this measure.
Particular-Tap1211 on
Next to hide under the counter, the black market alcohol
[deleted] on
[deleted]
Electronic-Space-736 on
Who are the suckers in the 20%? They really should smarten up.
enduringandsurviving on
What I see that isn’t mentioned or covered regarding the blackmarket is the major lack of quality control in illegal product.
Some of the darts smell and taste like straight formaldehyde.
Others have a moth ball odour to the paper.
I’ve heard heavy smokers buying packets of reds tell me there’s no “hit” of nicotine in it and they can smoke half a pack unsatisfied.
Been shown there’s large chunks of “tobacco” that don’t burn properly.
I’ve seen pieces of paper ripped up in the tobacco of emptied out smokes with one peice that said “happiness” which implied they’re chopping up, rerolling and rebranding double happiness for shitty replica name brand packaging.
I’ve had people tell me after a pack of black market that they have no sense of taste or can’t feel their tongue anymore.
Others don’t need to say anything, I can hear the deep chested coughing fits clearly.
I understand some think “oh poor smokers choosing that” but these anecdotes are from old age pensioners. People who were told smoking was okay in their time and had it sold, pushed and made socially acceptable in forming habit.
They’re not able to go ask Sheryl at the “novelty store” for a refund or their money back nor are they able to intimidate honest business.
They’re choosing to literally suck up unregulated unknown poisons because of ingrained habit and the fortnightly budget being sunk into a carton of unknown risk that they can’t refund.
And some keep going back to buy more because they’re not able to get a new source.
Any so called “Tax” in the name of funding healthcare is bullshit.
Removing affordability for a hooked older generation, enabling access to the younger generation with removing vapes or adding cheap blackmarket and giving a majority of people no choice but to put their money and faith in criminals that have no regard for damage or health fall out is going to cost the government and health services much more than whatever they get out of the 20% left paying out the nose for the rort.
Not even attempting the age out law like New Zealand or other deterrent tactics first is such a shame.
WeissPyre on
You mean making the legal cigarettes outrageously expensive by taxing the fuck out of them just drove people to the black market?
What?! Who could have foreseen this?!
/s government played itself.
cement-skeleton on
Time to hire Rex Banner to sort out this mess.
Mr_Lumbergh on
That’s what happens when you put de-facto prohibition on things. Prohibition has worked approximately zero times historically.
t_25_t on
“Criminals” doing more to help the working class people than the politicians voted in by the public.
We get taxed to the hilt on everything.
Old_Assistant4187 on
That’ll happen when you learn absolutely nothing from the war on drugs or alcohol prohibition. Our leadership is brain-dead as fuck.
kooky_kabuki on
Who are these people buying the legal stuff?? Are they made of money?
deadhead-steve on
Lol what a surprise! Like no shit Sherlock what the fuck else you think we gonna do?
AngrehPossum on
Well you did price it out of the market. By a long way. You’re doing it with Alcohol too.
facechubbs on
Short sighted government strategy… are we actually surprised?
48 Comments
That’s a huge number.
Is the official government line still “there’s no connection between high taxes and the black market”??
They taxed everyone so hard they created a blackmarket… Who’d have ever guessed….
I’d expect to see more of this stuff happening as the price of everything goes through the roof.
Our government is so idiotic its unbelievable, the tobacco wars and smuggling is something they have directly created – nobody else to blame. The taxes on smoking far outweigh the cost that smokers have on our public healthcare system. They also completely fucked up with vapes as well, I used to be able to easily buy nicotine and choose my own strengths, now all you can easily get is a ridiculously strong and overpriced disposable. Watch the same thing start happening with alcohol soon….
Its unfortunate that there’s still that 20% missing out
No one saw this coming, unprecedented, usually prohibition works flawlessly
I gave up when smokes got to about $35 a packet, that was two years ago. Tried nicotine aids and patches – fucking useless. Went cold turkey and it worked a treat.
I never could find a source for cheap smokes, otherwise I might have kept smoking.
It’s cheaper. Who can you blame?
Banning vapes and overtaxing cigarettes is going to go down as one of the dumbest public health decisions in history, I can’t believe that after years of progress with reducing the smoking rate that it’s going up again. It’s making it so much easier for kids to start smoking or vaping cos no one gives a shit about selling to teens anymore because it’s illegal already, it’s just a fucked situation and now the government won’t even have tax dollars to help cover the cost of all of the future health issues.
Congratulations to Tobacco for winning the war on Tobacco
*Just* 80% …?
Good on us
This checks out, of all of the people I know who smokes only one of them gets the legit durries
Why are we typing percentage as ‘pc’ instead of %
They should try prohibition next.
Oh, sorry, I thought the brief was for things that don’t work. My mistake.
This is fucking insanity.
Utter failure of governance.
The greedy idiots and puppets in government will never learn to cut down on their unchecked spendings instead of taxing the population to death.
People will find a way to survive the high taxation.
Up next sky is blue.
I moved here from New Zealand a month ago, and it has been absolutely mindblowing how much this country smells like cigarettes. NZ has a ton of vapers, but that doesn’t really smell. There are smokers absolutely everywhere here and it stinks.
Coming from a bartender I would estimate high 90%, I do not really ever see legal tobacco anywhere. Our tobacco vending machine is effectively never used. Doesn’t matter if they are a tourist who barely speaks english or a local.
We know ! we smell it.
Just lower the taxes, FFS
I still have no idea where to get cheap smokes.
Sick of paying $100+ for a pouch lmao.
Good fuck this overtaxing government.
Another scary number – Australians are using 40% more nicotine than in 2017.
That obviously includes vaping, but is yet another example of the complete and total failure of government policy
There’s five illegal cigarette vendors within walking distance of my local police station and they are not trying to hide their trade.
We have to reset the price of legal cigarettes slightly lower than the smuggled ones to drive them out.
I moved from Brisbane to Sydney this year and haven’t found a black market here yet. Seems way more locked down in comparison to Brisbane.
It’s currently $38 for a the cheapest pack of 20’s at colesworth
Is it true that every package of Manchester cigs is illegal?
I see the empty packs as gutter rubbish all the time, and someone once told me there is actually no way to buy them legit
If only we had lessons in history about trying to tax/prohibit something to the wahzoo.
Who would have thought/s
I wonder / hope they accounted for the increasing quantity of nicotine in the “illegal” / disposable vapes.
From a brief skim – cigarettes (blues) are 12-16 mg, reds edging up a bit over 20mg.
The maximum non prescription is 20mg.
Many of the disposables are hitting “5%” or 50mg, I’m aware of many being 10% 0r 100mg.
It’s not like for like and there are other factors, but raw number wise vapes, certainly, have more nicotine. Does this represent more people ingesting more tobacco products and vapes at what kind of ratio ?
I would say I’ve seen more people vaping but a shitload less pumping durries. My local bottle store just dropped selling them completely.
IMHO banning the “actual” OG vape stores with reusable, better made devices and consumable elements and at least a kind of rudimentary validation in so far as known “brands”, flavour and such – just lead to an onslaught of e-waste, cheeky battery juice mixes, poor quality electronics and the commercial viability of using rechargeable li-ion batteries in a disposable device.
Along with a raft of other chaos, fire bombings and rogue activity that was unprecedented outside of the repeated examples globally throughout previous decades, the current time and likely core elements of human behaviour.
Thought they were too expensive to buy at the $25 mark so never did. I smoke more now than I do back then, $10 is too good not to.
A massive failure of government and law enforcement.
And vascular disease related amputations have plummeted.
The tax and the plain packaging are good policies.
They will be ideal when the tax haul from tobacco is zero.
Now, arrest the illegal tobacco shops and importers and fine the Bejeezus out of them.
This was always going to happen. I hate smoking, but this was a very foreseeable outcome. Smokers are addicts, eventually they’ll have to find the hit in a way they can afford.
The Government’s border control is an absolute joke when you understand just what a massive volume of material that 80% of the tobacco market is. We don’t even share land borders with any other nation so there’s no hope of keeping the real nasty stuff out at this level of incompetence.
I quit from $4 to $5 a pack I though – thats awesome just jack up the price and everyone will quit. Yeh Nah. There was a limit to this measure.
Next to hide under the counter, the black market alcohol
[deleted]
Who are the suckers in the 20%? They really should smarten up.
What I see that isn’t mentioned or covered regarding the blackmarket is the major lack of quality control in illegal product.
Some of the darts smell and taste like straight formaldehyde.
Others have a moth ball odour to the paper.
I’ve heard heavy smokers buying packets of reds tell me there’s no “hit” of nicotine in it and they can smoke half a pack unsatisfied.
Been shown there’s large chunks of “tobacco” that don’t burn properly.
I’ve seen pieces of paper ripped up in the tobacco of emptied out smokes with one peice that said “happiness” which implied they’re chopping up, rerolling and rebranding double happiness for shitty replica name brand packaging.
I’ve had people tell me after a pack of black market that they have no sense of taste or can’t feel their tongue anymore.
Others don’t need to say anything, I can hear the deep chested coughing fits clearly.
I understand some think “oh poor smokers choosing that” but these anecdotes are from old age pensioners. People who were told smoking was okay in their time and had it sold, pushed and made socially acceptable in forming habit.
They’re not able to go ask Sheryl at the “novelty store” for a refund or their money back nor are they able to intimidate honest business.
They’re choosing to literally suck up unregulated unknown poisons because of ingrained habit and the fortnightly budget being sunk into a carton of unknown risk that they can’t refund.
And some keep going back to buy more because they’re not able to get a new source.
Any so called “Tax” in the name of funding healthcare is bullshit.
Removing affordability for a hooked older generation, enabling access to the younger generation with removing vapes or adding cheap blackmarket and giving a majority of people no choice but to put their money and faith in criminals that have no regard for damage or health fall out is going to cost the government and health services much more than whatever they get out of the 20% left paying out the nose for the rort.
Not even attempting the age out law like New Zealand or other deterrent tactics first is such a shame.
You mean making the legal cigarettes outrageously expensive by taxing the fuck out of them just drove people to the black market?
What?! Who could have foreseen this?!
/s government played itself.
Time to hire Rex Banner to sort out this mess.
That’s what happens when you put de-facto prohibition on things. Prohibition has worked approximately zero times historically.
“Criminals” doing more to help the working class people than the politicians voted in by the public.
We get taxed to the hilt on everything.
That’ll happen when you learn absolutely nothing from the war on drugs or alcohol prohibition. Our leadership is brain-dead as fuck.
Who are these people buying the legal stuff?? Are they made of money?
Lol what a surprise! Like no shit Sherlock what the fuck else you think we gonna do?
Well you did price it out of the market. By a long way. You’re doing it with Alcohol too.
Short sighted government strategy… are we actually surprised?