Why Arabic as a second language for so many people?
LowOwl4312 on
Im old, I still remember a time when Japanese, Russian and German were in the top 10
theboyqueen on
“Indonesian” would jump a few spots if you added Malay speakers to the total.
crivycouriac on
I can’t forget about how much the Dutch shot themselves in the foot with this
Instead of Indonesian, we could’ve had Dutch on this list
NecroDolphinn on
Indonesian and Malay should really be one language.
Also, Hindi and Urdu aren’t even considered different languages or dialects, linguists consider them registers of the same language, Hindustani. A register is like how we use formal speech in a workplace environment, which explains the difference in vocabulary between the two (as context guides whether to use more Arabic/Persian words or more Indo Aryan ones).
Lastly, MSA is taught to Arabic speakers, with local dialects really being more used in speech. The designation as just second speakers doesn’t really feel super salient.
EmperorThan on
Seeing Urdu on the list reminded me of when Obama said he had many Urdu poems he loved. lol
We’ve gone from an Urdu poetry lover to a UFC Cage Fight on the White House lawn in two Presidents…
7 Comments
Just made a simple visualization using CSS and HTML and the Ethnologue data on Wikipedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_languages_by_total_number_of_speakers
Why Arabic as a second language for so many people?
Im old, I still remember a time when Japanese, Russian and German were in the top 10
“Indonesian” would jump a few spots if you added Malay speakers to the total.
I can’t forget about how much the Dutch shot themselves in the foot with this
Instead of Indonesian, we could’ve had Dutch on this list
Indonesian and Malay should really be one language.
Also, Hindi and Urdu aren’t even considered different languages or dialects, linguists consider them registers of the same language, Hindustani. A register is like how we use formal speech in a workplace environment, which explains the difference in vocabulary between the two (as context guides whether to use more Arabic/Persian words or more Indo Aryan ones).
Lastly, MSA is taught to Arabic speakers, with local dialects really being more used in speech. The designation as just second speakers doesn’t really feel super salient.
Seeing Urdu on the list reminded me of when Obama said he had many Urdu poems he loved. lol
We’ve gone from an Urdu poetry lover to a UFC Cage Fight on the White House lawn in two Presidents…