
Women rate their sleep quality lower than men, despite sleeping better. This is because they estimate their night-time awakenings more accurately than men, who tend to underestimate their frequency of wakefulness
https://news.ki.se/women-sleep-better-than-men-but-experience-the-opposite
13 Comments
>The researchers investigated differences in sleep between men and women, in terms of both objective measures and perceived sleep quality. 238 women and 238 men in Sweden, aged 29–85, recorded their sleep at home over one night using polysomnography, a method that measures brain activity, breathing and movements during sleep. The following morning, the participants rated their sleep quality.
>
>The results, published in the journal Sleep Advances, reveal a clear pattern. On average, women rated their sleep quality as poorer than men, even though the objective measurements showed that they slept better. Among other things, the women had fewer awakenings per hour, a longer total sleep time, a higher sleep efficiency, and more deep sleep than the men.
>
>Gender differences in memory
>
>Women estimated the number of times they woke up during the night much more accurately than men, who underestimated how often they had been awake. On average, men spent less time awake each time they woke up. Men with short awakenings generally rated their sleep quality as good, whereas women generally rated their sleep quality as poorer, regardless of the duration of their awakenings.
>
>When the researchers excluded men with short, barely noticeable awakenings from the analyses, the difference in self-reported sleep quality between the sexes disappeared.
>Differences increased with age
>
>The study also shows that differences in sleep between men and women become more pronounced with age. At older ages, men experienced less deep sleep and more awakenings per hour, while women’s objective sleep deteriorated to a lesser extent. At the same time, women continued to report poorer sleep quality than men.
>
>One limitation of the study is that sleep was measured over a single night and does not necessarily reflect long-term sleep patterns.
[Gender differences in objective and self-reported sleep | SLEEP Advances | Oxford Academic](https://academic.oup.com/sleepadvances/article/7/2/zpag048/8663014)
So, you’re saying that women have better data but draw worse conclusions from it? …I have doubts about your story.
“Men’s standards are too low. Women are pickier.”
I know this is r/science and anecdotes aren’t the idea…but I really feel like you would find similarly “gendered” results in all sorts of areas. This seems to track with men and women’s experiences/perceptions, generally.
Big issue for those of us with sleep apnea. Even with my CPAP machine I’m waking four or five times a night. The machine tells me how long it was on each night, but I have difficulty judging how long it was after I put the machine on until I actually fell asleep. As a consequence I try for 9 hours of CPAP usage a night to get 8 hours of sleep, but frankly that’s a guess. (I’m male FWIW.)
I rarely ever recall waking in the night, once or twice a month at most.
How would I estimate waking if I have no memory of it? Or am I just getting unusually continuous sleep?
>It’s a paradox, but we have found a possible explanation for why sleep quality is perceived so differently by men and women
This is really a common topic? The perception in sleep quality between men and women? Something so biologically essential is going to be incredibly discretionary based on the individual, including their perception. Odd study
Women are right because they’re more wrong, and wrong because they’re more right.
Women wear smartwatches more than men, so this tracks
I’m a woman and I seem to wake up 30 times a night and my husband is like a log next to me. It drives me crazy. I’ve been tested for sleep apnea and I don’t have it. My hips and shoulders hurt and my arms go numb and my head hurts on my pillow and I get too hot and then too cold and I can’t sleep on my back because I get sleep paralysis demons so I just feel like I’m constantly flipping back and forth trying to be comfortable.
Wait, why are we comparing the “objective” quality of sleep of men vs women? We already know that women actually need more sleep than men to feel properly rested. So measuring sleep in men and women in an “objective” way, ie assuming both sexes should have THE SAME amount of deep sleep/awakenings/REM/whatever is gonna be wrong.
So isn’t this study, once again, taking the “objectively good” quality of sleep (aka “what is good enough for a man”) and then comparing women’s Q of sleep to that, just to then arrive at the predictable conclusion of “aha! Their sleep is fine, they just complain about it more!”?
Oddly enough, I (M) hate using any gadget that tells me how I’ve slept. It always says I slept terribly. Then I feel terrible. No gadget and I feel fine.
The brain is a curious thing.
What awakenings? Am I supposed to awake more than once?