another irish times article noone can read or maybe dont want to read 🤣
we should be concentrating on highest skilled migrants not just piling everybody in year after year with not even houses for the new people, madness
PosterPrintPerfect on
*”to do the jobs the Irish won’t do”*
What exactly are these jobs that the Irish won’t do?
miju-irl on
Key extract from the article
>average immigrant couple who arrive here at age 30 and go to work, the main breadwinner must be in the 65th percentile, meaning earning at least €62,000 a year, in order to pay their way over their lifetime.
>For immigrants from female seclusion societies where the culture means women don’t go to work, the primary earner in that scenario must be in the 85th percentile, meaning that man has to earn over €95,000 for that couple to pay their way.
>If a country has a very progressive tax system, meaning that low-wage workers pay very little income tax and a worker gets taxed more as they earn more, like Ireland, it will affect the overall lifetime contribution an immigrant will make, particularly a low-wage immigrant.
>In addition, in a country that provides a flat state pension to everyone, like Ireland (irrespective of how much tax that person has paid over their working life), the retired migrant will take out more than they have paid into the system.
G1ForceX on
we have all been gaslit by the current crop in government for many many years that we need all these people & even that its essential we repopulate the country, what a load of crap, the government created policies that result in large numbers leaving the country from certain professions (health) and have now flooded the country 23% foreign born but now realise that other eu countries that did this are having lots of issues and are actually backtracking on policies but we are left with the same ole clowns determined to just keep ploughing on regardless
WT_Wiliams on
“for the average immigrant couple who arrive here at age 30 and go to work, the main breadwinner must be in the 65th percentile, meaning earning at least €62,000 a year, in order to pay their way over their lifetime. For immigrants from female seclusion societies where the culture means women don’t go to work, the primary earner in that scenario must be in the 85th percentile, meaning that man has to earn over €95,000 for that couple to pay their way.
The Irish tax and welfare system has been designed to ease the burden on single low-wage families, so a family – migrant or native – with one earner making half the average salary (€27,000) receives around €11,151 per year from this State, in effect a support from the rest of society. This compares with average earners (€52,200) who, when tax and welfare are taken into account, pay into the State €8,294 per year. If you earn twice the average salary (€104,000), you will pay €40,362.”
MrWhiteside97 on
> If we want to take in lots of low-skilled migrants
If we did have a huge low-skilled migrant workforce, we would need to consider this, but it feels like a solution in search of a problem right now.
Specific-Manager-125 on
I’ll admit to usually being reviled by McWilliams but he makes some good points ……….
leavemealonethanks on
Ever since I heard McWilliams speak, with complete confidence, utter utter shite of putting blame on civil servants for the government feck ups I haven’t taken anything he’s said without a pinch of salt.
21stCenturyVole on
Right now housing is the primary consideration that matters here, as any continued influx of workers from abroad, is deliberately being used as Class Warfare – directly attacking peoples ability to afford a home, as well as attacking their working conditions.
A continuation of net inward migration, should only be allowed when the housing and job markets can sustain it – and they can’t.
G1ForceX on
This is a june this year graph of the number of first time asylum applications per 100,000 people relating to different eu countries
notice we are near the top at 19.3 first time applicants per 100k people, germany for example has 5 per 100k people, with countries like poland at 1 and portugal at 0.7
‘In June 2026, the highest rates of first-time applicants per 100 000 people continued to be recorded in Greece (38.2), ahead of Ireland (19.3) and Latvia (19.0).’
Oh if it isn’t the facts the right wingers have been shouting for years
Immortal_Tuttle on
I don’t have anything against free workforce movement and common EU market. I do have something against open human trafficking done under the cover of MSc or similar university courses.
Currently to get an MSc in computer science even on some sought for majors like AI (not prompting…) you can get it done under 3 years. So what’s new? Basically the educational part takes 4 months and it’s on maybe basic Leaving cert level. You take 4 months of online lectures (not live) you are going to the uni to take written exams (1day), you submit your work and after being approved – done. I looked up those courses and exams. You literally can’t fail…
12 Comments
another irish times article noone can read or maybe dont want to read 🤣
we should be concentrating on highest skilled migrants not just piling everybody in year after year with not even houses for the new people, madness
*”to do the jobs the Irish won’t do”*
What exactly are these jobs that the Irish won’t do?
Key extract from the article
>average immigrant couple who arrive here at age 30 and go to work, the main breadwinner must be in the 65th percentile, meaning earning at least €62,000 a year, in order to pay their way over their lifetime.
>For immigrants from female seclusion societies where the culture means women don’t go to work, the primary earner in that scenario must be in the 85th percentile, meaning that man has to earn over €95,000 for that couple to pay their way.
>If a country has a very progressive tax system, meaning that low-wage workers pay very little income tax and a worker gets taxed more as they earn more, like Ireland, it will affect the overall lifetime contribution an immigrant will make, particularly a low-wage immigrant.
>In addition, in a country that provides a flat state pension to everyone, like Ireland (irrespective of how much tax that person has paid over their working life), the retired migrant will take out more than they have paid into the system.
we have all been gaslit by the current crop in government for many many years that we need all these people & even that its essential we repopulate the country, what a load of crap, the government created policies that result in large numbers leaving the country from certain professions (health) and have now flooded the country 23% foreign born but now realise that other eu countries that did this are having lots of issues and are actually backtracking on policies but we are left with the same ole clowns determined to just keep ploughing on regardless
“for the average immigrant couple who arrive here at age 30 and go to work, the main breadwinner must be in the 65th percentile, meaning earning at least €62,000 a year, in order to pay their way over their lifetime. For immigrants from female seclusion societies where the culture means women don’t go to work, the primary earner in that scenario must be in the 85th percentile, meaning that man has to earn over €95,000 for that couple to pay their way.
The Irish tax and welfare system has been designed to ease the burden on single low-wage families, so a family – migrant or native – with one earner making half the average salary (€27,000) receives around €11,151 per year from this State, in effect a support from the rest of society. This compares with average earners (€52,200) who, when tax and welfare are taken into account, pay into the State €8,294 per year. If you earn twice the average salary (€104,000), you will pay €40,362.”
> If we want to take in lots of low-skilled migrants
…and who says we do? McWilliams lays out that we have high volume of migrants, but doesn’t ever clarify whether they are the “low skilled” workers he’s talking about. Non-Irish nationals are actually much more highly skilled in general – https://www.cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/ep/p-eda/educationalattainmentthematicreport2024/profileofagesexnationalityandregion/
If we did have a huge low-skilled migrant workforce, we would need to consider this, but it feels like a solution in search of a problem right now.
I’ll admit to usually being reviled by McWilliams but he makes some good points ……….
Ever since I heard McWilliams speak, with complete confidence, utter utter shite of putting blame on civil servants for the government feck ups I haven’t taken anything he’s said without a pinch of salt.
Right now housing is the primary consideration that matters here, as any continued influx of workers from abroad, is deliberately being used as Class Warfare – directly attacking peoples ability to afford a home, as well as attacking their working conditions.
A continuation of net inward migration, should only be allowed when the housing and job markets can sustain it – and they can’t.
This is a june this year graph of the number of first time asylum applications per 100,000 people relating to different eu countries
https://preview.redd.it/8ebdb08f45sh1.png?width=730&format=png&auto=webp&s=3bcbb2fe9dac0a380f314bf911918cbe2eb7bff9
notice we are near the top at 19.3 first time applicants per 100k people, germany for example has 5 per 100k people, with countries like poland at 1 and portugal at 0.7
‘In June 2026, the highest rates of first-time applicants per 100 000 people continued to be recorded in Greece (38.2), ahead of Ireland (19.3) and Latvia (19.0).’
[https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Asylum_applications_-_monthly_statistics](https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Asylum_applications_-_monthly_statistics)
Oh if it isn’t the facts the right wingers have been shouting for years
I don’t have anything against free workforce movement and common EU market. I do have something against open human trafficking done under the cover of MSc or similar university courses.
Currently to get an MSc in computer science even on some sought for majors like AI (not prompting…) you can get it done under 3 years. So what’s new? Basically the educational part takes 4 months and it’s on maybe basic Leaving cert level. You take 4 months of online lectures (not live) you are going to the uni to take written exams (1day), you submit your work and after being approved – done. I looked up those courses and exams. You literally can’t fail…