They have no other source of hope for the future, and the priests seem to be keeping it in their pants now.
twoidesofrecoil on
Makes sense. i think religion back in our parents’ day was more harshly instilled. Even the Catholic church is trying to move towards an arguably more liberal image + spirituality in its broader forms is becoming more popular. the vast majority of friends i have aren’t atheists.
00DEADBEEF on
I guess life is so shit now they have no choice to turn to fairy tales to tell them what to do so things might be less shit when they’re dead
backagainlool on
Maybe it’s because Gen Z is far more likely to come from backgrounds other than white British
I’m an atheist because my parents are and I believe both sets of my grandparents are
However if my parents were religious then it’s far more likely that I’d be religious
1 in 3 children are now being born to mothers who were born outside the country who are more likely to be religious than British mothers
limeflavoured on
And their kids will probably be less religious than them. Things like this tend to be quite cyclic.
DarthFlowers on
The generation who are the pioneers of cultural decline. Jesus is my algorithm brooooooo
VictoriouslyAviation on
So people are turning their backs on the established religions – I’m generally happy with that.
But they are using TikTok to research <checks notes> Astrology. There was a time when the likes of Mystic Meg and Russell Grant were considered amusingly eccentric and were indulged with a sort of affectionate disdain. Now it’s making billions amplified by a Chinese data farm.
I’m going to avoid the hysteria often attributed to people my age that ‘the kids are not alright’ as I’m very sure that this is a phase; like shell suits and fidget spinners. But could somebody please press fast forward to the ‘Post TikTok Epoch’ – it’s all very silly.
BenDawes on
Stupid headline. They’re hardly old enough to be grandparents now are they?
Jurassic_Bun on
I mean I feel rather spiritual and I am a millennial. I prefer to believe there is something waiting rather than nothing, especially with how life has been. In the past people live in a greater sense of optimism whereas today it seems society is approaching a new phase or the end stage of what we had.
LifeMasterpiece6475 on
Like most of these surveys, it depends who they ask and where they ask them.
An extreme example would be the survey was only in the back of a church magazine. Or they stood outside mosques asking the question.
Most surveys can be manipulated to give the answer the person paying for it wants.
flashbastrd on
I’ve realised in recent years how paradoxical atheism is in the sense that it carries this weight of intelligence and scientificness when it’s actually an incredibly stupid and nonsensical theory.
We have an infinitely huge universe, our planet is teeming with incomprehensibly intelligent life forms that we fool ourselves into believing we understand. And all of that is meant to be totally meaningless and pointless? Something can’t exist without it having been created.
For the developed world mostly gone are the days of believing there’s a superhuman man who lives in the clouds. But to genuinely believe that existence is nothing, really misses the point that we exist at all.
I think this is what gen Z are coping onto. Atheism IMO was an extreme rejection of the dogma of religion, but we’re moving past that now, and atheism is nothing but dogma in and of itself.
Also, when I was growing up it would be embarrassing to say you believed in God, smart-asses would explain how science has disproven the theory of a God, and you were ridiculed for being stupid if you said you believed in a higher power.
This is also less prevalent today due to public ridicule being more of a faux pas than it used to be.
pullingteeths on
Not identifying themselves by the term atheist doesn’t mean they’re religious or not actually atheist. The term just has some negative connotations and is seen as uncool now. There is currently a rising trend of anti intellectualism that doesn’t help.
*Many* people have no belief in a god (the definition of atheist) but don’t define themselves as atheist due to misunderstanding the definition or believing it makes them sound closed minded.
Kind_Dream_610 on
Gen Z are also more likely to engage online, and as a result, unfortunately, are often more likely to believe what their peers believe or tell them is true, or that influences peddle.
Worth_Tip_7894 on
Whatever the reason for this, it doesn’t stem from reason.
Sad news.
MR_Girkin on
Uf you read the article the entire study is dodgy no info on the survey aside from the number surveyed so no clue who made it and what the questions where the % for certain groups aren’t reflective of the population at all and it was made and funded by a author who makes his money writing very pro-christian books.
Also the ingo in the study doesn’t even match the headline folk are arguing over very clear misinformation and click bait.
thebigman85 on
It’s purely down to a demographic shift in the country
More oppressive and forced religions become more prevalent so the tradition of being religious is carried on
It’s sad imo really, people should have free choice. But if you’re born into it you have no choice. Just told god exists and you now have to live your life around faith in something that we pretty much know isn’t real
RejectingBoredom on
A lot of guys under 30 I know have started identifying with “cultural Christianity” a lot more, and even some younger women I know identify as spiritual and believe in God[TM] but don’t necessarily subscribe to religion
I’d be curious, if we got into the weeds, how much of this is actual belief in an existential god versus “it feels beneficial to believe in something” thinking
AlfredTheMid on
Interestingly, even in societies where religion is outlawed and never taught – once those restrictions are lifted, people gravitate towards religion.
Whether atheists like it or not, human beings appear to be inherently and naturally religious.
Fit-Obligation4962 on
Im not anti immigrant at all but one downside to migrants is the religion and bigotry they bring with them
Muted-City-Fan on
Who’s surprised? Islam increases, immigration increases. Islam is the only growing religion in the world right?
TheBrownNomad on
Guven all the brainrot and social media I wont be surprised.
Crispy116 on
So what we are saying is that we live in a complete misinformation age now.
People used to just get their misinformation from church and perhaps tabloid media, but with the advent of the internet and social media, Gen Z are so open to misinformation that they are once more embracing the overwhelming BS that is religion.
Alongside the other crap they believe, religion barely registers on their shit-detector.
turbosprouts on
The report on the survey has lots of pretty charts but doesn’t provide access to any raw data.
The survey participants are grouped into 4 categories:
30% nonbelievers
40% uncommitted
17% religious
70% spiritual
that’s a ‘representative contingent of all levels of belief’. Clearly some heavy overlap in categories (total: 157%). Most interesting is the ‘spiritual’ category.
What about the assertion that genZ are very spiritual? Well, on p7 of the report they say ‘64% of genz would describe themselves as spiritual’. The stats for genz according to the report are:
64% describe themselves as spiritual
48% describe themselves as uncommitted
28% describe themselves as religious
24% describe themselves as nonbelievers
Again, these categories aren’t exclusive. presumably every religious person is included in the ‘spiritual’ group, but it’s hard to say.
So what is spirituality? The report doesn’t define what it means, but does seem to conflate ‘spirituality’ and ‘religious’ in the text commentary
On p12 they detail the ‘top ways brits express their spirituality’:
45% ‘enjoy nature’ to express their spirituality
26% ‘enjoy music or art’ to express their spirituality
29% ‘connect with other people’ to express their spirituality
25% exercise
10% ‘support a sports team or fandom’ to express their spirituality.
That’s not a complete list – but if you listen to spotify, go to the gym or hang out with your mates at the weekend, congrats — you’re a really spiritual person!
—
I’d love to ask the survey team some questions
* did you have a definition of ‘spiritual’ for your participants, or rely on self-reporting based on each individual’s personal understanding of the word ‘spiritual’
* how did you group participants into your four categories
* where did the list of spiritual expressions come from?
MaxCherry64 on
A society without hope turns to religion for comfort. This is hardly surprising. Also, are we talking about Muslim faith, Christians…either way, this is not a surprise to me.
NagelRawls on
Spiritual doesn’t necessarily mean they believe in a divine creator. Granted different generation but my mother calls herself spiritual because she believes in ghost and what not.
BeastMidlands on
I can’t actually believe I’ve grown up being told that there’s a left-wing liberal elite running everything while seemingly the whole world has been lurching right for years and years
redunculuspanda on
“Spiritual” is just another world for gullible. I know a lot of the kinds of people and it’s all antivax and conspiracy craziness.
An increasing levels of stupidity is all we need.
RussellLawliet on
No indication in the survey about how it was conducted other than that it was done by OnePoll. If the survey’s name was something to do with religion or spirituality then it would naturally self-select towards those who are religious or spiritual.
bunglemullet on
Due to hegemonic and heretical influences of US TV and ‘prosperity theology ‘
Robynsxx on
What? They are getting brainwashed by religion again?
Inkyyy98 on
I’m not surprised. I want to say spiritual isn’t the same as religious, so I don’t think the churches are going to start filling up with young people. There is an increase in people (myself included) who identify as pagan, which is such a broad term. Some of us believe in gods of various pantheons, others don’t believe in gods but are still spiritual.
indifferent-times on
>younger generation the least likely to call themselves atheists
Church of England, which show close to a third of churches have “zero children” among their congregation.
the usual confusion about what atheism is, the clue really is in the name, its about not believing in god, nothing else. Happy to accept that gen Z dont know any better either, but the gap between ‘spiritual’ and ‘religious’ is huge, healing crystals and dream-catchers are not a religion, its still dressed up hippy woo.
BusyBeeBridgette on
Just because a person is spiritual doesn’t, necessarily, mean they are religious. Lumping Spirituality and Religion together is doing some awfully heavy lifting to make the logic of the article seem legit.
33 Comments
They have no other source of hope for the future, and the priests seem to be keeping it in their pants now.
Makes sense. i think religion back in our parents’ day was more harshly instilled. Even the Catholic church is trying to move towards an arguably more liberal image + spirituality in its broader forms is becoming more popular. the vast majority of friends i have aren’t atheists.
I guess life is so shit now they have no choice to turn to fairy tales to tell them what to do so things might be less shit when they’re dead
Maybe it’s because Gen Z is far more likely to come from backgrounds other than white British
I’m an atheist because my parents are and I believe both sets of my grandparents are
However if my parents were religious then it’s far more likely that I’d be religious
1 in 3 children are now being born to mothers who were born outside the country who are more likely to be religious than British mothers
And their kids will probably be less religious than them. Things like this tend to be quite cyclic.
The generation who are the pioneers of cultural decline. Jesus is my algorithm brooooooo
So people are turning their backs on the established religions – I’m generally happy with that.
But they are using TikTok to research <checks notes> Astrology. There was a time when the likes of Mystic Meg and Russell Grant were considered amusingly eccentric and were indulged with a sort of affectionate disdain. Now it’s making billions amplified by a Chinese data farm.
I’m going to avoid the hysteria often attributed to people my age that ‘the kids are not alright’ as I’m very sure that this is a phase; like shell suits and fidget spinners. But could somebody please press fast forward to the ‘Post TikTok Epoch’ – it’s all very silly.
Stupid headline. They’re hardly old enough to be grandparents now are they?
I mean I feel rather spiritual and I am a millennial. I prefer to believe there is something waiting rather than nothing, especially with how life has been. In the past people live in a greater sense of optimism whereas today it seems society is approaching a new phase or the end stage of what we had.
Like most of these surveys, it depends who they ask and where they ask them.
An extreme example would be the survey was only in the back of a church magazine. Or they stood outside mosques asking the question.
Most surveys can be manipulated to give the answer the person paying for it wants.
I’ve realised in recent years how paradoxical atheism is in the sense that it carries this weight of intelligence and scientificness when it’s actually an incredibly stupid and nonsensical theory.
We have an infinitely huge universe, our planet is teeming with incomprehensibly intelligent life forms that we fool ourselves into believing we understand. And all of that is meant to be totally meaningless and pointless? Something can’t exist without it having been created.
For the developed world mostly gone are the days of believing there’s a superhuman man who lives in the clouds. But to genuinely believe that existence is nothing, really misses the point that we exist at all.
I think this is what gen Z are coping onto. Atheism IMO was an extreme rejection of the dogma of religion, but we’re moving past that now, and atheism is nothing but dogma in and of itself.
Also, when I was growing up it would be embarrassing to say you believed in God, smart-asses would explain how science has disproven the theory of a God, and you were ridiculed for being stupid if you said you believed in a higher power.
This is also less prevalent today due to public ridicule being more of a faux pas than it used to be.
Not identifying themselves by the term atheist doesn’t mean they’re religious or not actually atheist. The term just has some negative connotations and is seen as uncool now. There is currently a rising trend of anti intellectualism that doesn’t help.
*Many* people have no belief in a god (the definition of atheist) but don’t define themselves as atheist due to misunderstanding the definition or believing it makes them sound closed minded.
Gen Z are also more likely to engage online, and as a result, unfortunately, are often more likely to believe what their peers believe or tell them is true, or that influences peddle.
Whatever the reason for this, it doesn’t stem from reason.
Sad news.
Uf you read the article the entire study is dodgy no info on the survey aside from the number surveyed so no clue who made it and what the questions where the % for certain groups aren’t reflective of the population at all and it was made and funded by a author who makes his money writing very pro-christian books.
Also the ingo in the study doesn’t even match the headline folk are arguing over very clear misinformation and click bait.
It’s purely down to a demographic shift in the country
More oppressive and forced religions become more prevalent so the tradition of being religious is carried on
It’s sad imo really, people should have free choice. But if you’re born into it you have no choice. Just told god exists and you now have to live your life around faith in something that we pretty much know isn’t real
A lot of guys under 30 I know have started identifying with “cultural Christianity” a lot more, and even some younger women I know identify as spiritual and believe in God[TM] but don’t necessarily subscribe to religion
I’d be curious, if we got into the weeds, how much of this is actual belief in an existential god versus “it feels beneficial to believe in something” thinking
Interestingly, even in societies where religion is outlawed and never taught – once those restrictions are lifted, people gravitate towards religion.
Whether atheists like it or not, human beings appear to be inherently and naturally religious.
Im not anti immigrant at all but one downside to migrants is the religion and bigotry they bring with them
Who’s surprised? Islam increases, immigration increases. Islam is the only growing religion in the world right?
Guven all the brainrot and social media I wont be surprised.
So what we are saying is that we live in a complete misinformation age now.
People used to just get their misinformation from church and perhaps tabloid media, but with the advent of the internet and social media, Gen Z are so open to misinformation that they are once more embracing the overwhelming BS that is religion.
Alongside the other crap they believe, religion barely registers on their shit-detector.
The report on the survey has lots of pretty charts but doesn’t provide access to any raw data.
The survey participants are grouped into 4 categories:
30% nonbelievers
40% uncommitted
17% religious
70% spiritual
that’s a ‘representative contingent of all levels of belief’. Clearly some heavy overlap in categories (total: 157%). Most interesting is the ‘spiritual’ category.
What about the assertion that genZ are very spiritual? Well, on p7 of the report they say ‘64% of genz would describe themselves as spiritual’. The stats for genz according to the report are:
64% describe themselves as spiritual
48% describe themselves as uncommitted
28% describe themselves as religious
24% describe themselves as nonbelievers
Again, these categories aren’t exclusive. presumably every religious person is included in the ‘spiritual’ group, but it’s hard to say.
So what is spirituality? The report doesn’t define what it means, but does seem to conflate ‘spirituality’ and ‘religious’ in the text commentary
On p12 they detail the ‘top ways brits express their spirituality’:
45% ‘enjoy nature’ to express their spirituality
26% ‘enjoy music or art’ to express their spirituality
29% ‘connect with other people’ to express their spirituality
25% exercise
10% ‘support a sports team or fandom’ to express their spirituality.
That’s not a complete list – but if you listen to spotify, go to the gym or hang out with your mates at the weekend, congrats — you’re a really spiritual person!
—
I’d love to ask the survey team some questions
* did you have a definition of ‘spiritual’ for your participants, or rely on self-reporting based on each individual’s personal understanding of the word ‘spiritual’
* how did you group participants into your four categories
* where did the list of spiritual expressions come from?
A society without hope turns to religion for comfort. This is hardly surprising. Also, are we talking about Muslim faith, Christians…either way, this is not a surprise to me.
Spiritual doesn’t necessarily mean they believe in a divine creator. Granted different generation but my mother calls herself spiritual because she believes in ghost and what not.
I can’t actually believe I’ve grown up being told that there’s a left-wing liberal elite running everything while seemingly the whole world has been lurching right for years and years
“Spiritual” is just another world for gullible. I know a lot of the kinds of people and it’s all antivax and conspiracy craziness.
An increasing levels of stupidity is all we need.
No indication in the survey about how it was conducted other than that it was done by OnePoll. If the survey’s name was something to do with religion or spirituality then it would naturally self-select towards those who are religious or spiritual.
Due to hegemonic and heretical influences of US TV and ‘prosperity theology ‘
What? They are getting brainwashed by religion again?
I’m not surprised. I want to say spiritual isn’t the same as religious, so I don’t think the churches are going to start filling up with young people. There is an increase in people (myself included) who identify as pagan, which is such a broad term. Some of us believe in gods of various pantheons, others don’t believe in gods but are still spiritual.
>younger generation the least likely to call themselves atheists
Church of England, which show close to a third of churches have “zero children” among their congregation.
the usual confusion about what atheism is, the clue really is in the name, its about not believing in god, nothing else. Happy to accept that gen Z dont know any better either, but the gap between ‘spiritual’ and ‘religious’ is huge, healing crystals and dream-catchers are not a religion, its still dressed up hippy woo.
Just because a person is spiritual doesn’t, necessarily, mean they are religious. Lumping Spirituality and Religion together is doing some awfully heavy lifting to make the logic of the article seem legit.