From the article: Bill Gates has an ominous warning for young people: there are four or five “very scary” things that they should be afraid of. In addition to the persistent fear of nuclear war, the Microsoft founder says unchecked AI is also a threat.
In an interview with Patrick Collinson, Gates said the only thing he really worried about a lot when he was younger was nuclear war.
While that particular concern hasn’t disappeared, Gates says younger generations now have extra threats to society that they must live with: climate change, bioterrorism or another pandemic, and maintaining control of advanced AI.
There have been plenty of previous warnings about AI advancing too quickly, reaching a point where it becomes smarter than humans and decides the world would be better off without us in it.
A survey in 2023 found that two-thirds of Americans believed AI could threaten civilization, and Professor Geoffrey Hinton, one of the godfathers of AI, believes there could be an AI that presents an extinction-level event in five to twenty years. Hinton left Google in 2023 due to concerns that AI was advancing faster than expected and could become uncontrollable.
Gates isn’t anti-AI, though. He believes that the technology could be used for good, such as filling skill gaps.
FUThead2016 on
lol all if these hype masters this rich parasite is one of the people who will profit from all of these terrors. People like him are responsible for the state of the planet.
TheApocalypseDaddy on
When will we stop listening to people we’re forced to listen to? Taking life advice from Bill gates is like taking guitar lessons from a goddamn tractor.
NovaHorizon on
I think Musk is proving right now that the greedy billionaire / multi millionaire class, Gates included, belongs on and at the top of that list.
CondiMesmer on
Can we just ban this overdone AI fear mongering? It’s just marketing hype and the products are struggling to drive actual return on investments. They’re also plateauing and they’re still just glorified auto corrects. They have no way of verifying information which makes them completely unviable in tons of fields since hallucinations are such a fundamental deal breaking issue.
Stop listening to the snake oil salesmen on what it “could” be, but rather look at the actual progress and current applications. When you actually look into companies attempting to live up to their overblown hype, you’ll realize none of them have actually been able to follow up their claims.
lokey_convo on
Where is that goose meme when you need it… If AI is a threat, then what the heck is Cortana and “Recall” for Bill? Huh?!? What is it Bill???
djaybe on
Humans have made a strong case for why a smarter species would come to that conclusion.
FreshDrama3024 on
What a fear mongering prick. But I will say that there is probably some validity of what he’s saying. I remember when Covid happened he made some ominous warning that we won’t be ready for the next pandemic just prior to Covid kicking off. Not saying he’s prophet, but it was too coincidental. Won’t be surprise if something happens sooner than later now.
djaybe on
“filling skill gaps” – Short term? Sure and it’s great!
Long term this will not matter.
TylerDurdenBigD on
The real threat was being a women working for Microsoft when this guys was at the office
trpytlby on
id be a lot less scared of AI if it wasnt being used to automate all the cognitive labour before the physical labour with probably that teensy tiny negligible exception of yknow military production and automated weapon systems lmfaooo
it would be kinda hilarious how obvious the trajectory is if it were not so terrifying
Pitiful_Response7547 on
Bill Gates is an evil country and he can go fuck his self
jcrestor on
My threat list:
1) Billionaire oligarchs
2) Social Media brainwashing
3) Right-Wing extremism
4) Wars
And as many wars are started by right-wing extremists, that came into power by mass manipulation in social media that are in the hands of billionaire oligarchs, I would say the first and foremost global threat and source of all these evils are BILLIONAIRE OLIGARCHS.
SpankyMcFlych on
I think useful general AI is going to be like flying cars, always just around the corner. The fears of AI improving exponentially have yet to appear and what we have now makes things up half the time and doesn’t understand what it’s saying/drawing, it’s just a complex regurgitator.
Background-Watch-660 on
The only thing AI is a threat to is our positively mediaeval notion that the average person needs a job in order to deserve income.
UBI is entirely possible. Distributing labor-free money to consumers would allow all of us to receive more goods and services while working less. The logical result of new technologies like AI being invented is that the UBI should increase, allowing the employment level to go down. Robots and AI *should* be enabling prosperous unemployment already, but they simply can’t because our UBI is missing.
Any amount of UBI we can sustain higher than $0 without inflation is equivalent with a boost in real income and market performance. That is a mathematical fact. There’s no economics-based argument against UBI; it improves consumer outcomes almost by definition.
The only thing standing in the way of greater income and greater leisure time for the average person is our culture’s backwards attitudes about jobs, labor and technology. We envision the economy as a giant workplace to fill up with billions of jobs; we aren’t even *trying* to use our technology to save labor and discover a more optimal labor/leisure balance.
The idea that AI should be feared because it might “steal our jobs” is evidence of just how confused our society is about what a job even is. A job isn’t a benefit, it’s a cost to our time and personal freedom which we are compensated for in the form of a wage.
Jobs are useful, but it *never* made sense to maximize the occurrence of jobs or to restrict income to the tune of wages. This is tantamount to wasting people’s time and keeping people needlessly poor.
We need an ample and properly calibrated UBI, to allow people all the leisure time that the modern market economies actually make possible. We should have implemented UBI around the start of the Industrial Revolution; by now it is long overdue.
MirceaHM on
Sure is he gonna spend his billions to do anything about it, or just get paid to give unwanted advice by media corporations?
dustofdeath on
AI is somewhere down in the list at 10+ issues.
But billionaires keep using it as a distraction.
And unlike all the other issues, it also comes with massive benefits at the same time.
17 Comments
From the article: Bill Gates has an ominous warning for young people: there are four or five “very scary” things that they should be afraid of. In addition to the persistent fear of nuclear war, the Microsoft founder says unchecked AI is also a threat.
In an interview with Patrick Collinson, Gates said the only thing he really worried about a lot when he was younger was nuclear war.
While that particular concern hasn’t disappeared, Gates says younger generations now have extra threats to society that they must live with: climate change, bioterrorism or another pandemic, and maintaining control of advanced AI.
There have been plenty of previous warnings about AI advancing too quickly, reaching a point where it becomes smarter than humans and decides the world would be better off without us in it.
A survey in 2023 found that two-thirds of Americans believed AI could threaten civilization, and Professor Geoffrey Hinton, one of the godfathers of AI, believes there could be an AI that presents an extinction-level event in five to twenty years. Hinton left Google in 2023 due to concerns that AI was advancing faster than expected and could become uncontrollable.
Gates isn’t anti-AI, though. He believes that the technology could be used for good, such as filling skill gaps.
lol all if these hype masters this rich parasite is one of the people who will profit from all of these terrors. People like him are responsible for the state of the planet.
When will we stop listening to people we’re forced to listen to? Taking life advice from Bill gates is like taking guitar lessons from a goddamn tractor.
I think Musk is proving right now that the greedy billionaire / multi millionaire class, Gates included, belongs on and at the top of that list.
Can we just ban this overdone AI fear mongering? It’s just marketing hype and the products are struggling to drive actual return on investments. They’re also plateauing and they’re still just glorified auto corrects. They have no way of verifying information which makes them completely unviable in tons of fields since hallucinations are such a fundamental deal breaking issue.
Stop listening to the snake oil salesmen on what it “could” be, but rather look at the actual progress and current applications. When you actually look into companies attempting to live up to their overblown hype, you’ll realize none of them have actually been able to follow up their claims.
Where is that goose meme when you need it… If AI is a threat, then what the heck is Cortana and “Recall” for Bill? Huh?!? What is it Bill???
Humans have made a strong case for why a smarter species would come to that conclusion.
What a fear mongering prick. But I will say that there is probably some validity of what he’s saying. I remember when Covid happened he made some ominous warning that we won’t be ready for the next pandemic just prior to Covid kicking off. Not saying he’s prophet, but it was too coincidental. Won’t be surprise if something happens sooner than later now.
“filling skill gaps” – Short term? Sure and it’s great!
Long term this will not matter.
The real threat was being a women working for Microsoft when this guys was at the office
id be a lot less scared of AI if it wasnt being used to automate all the cognitive labour before the physical labour with probably that teensy tiny negligible exception of yknow military production and automated weapon systems lmfaooo
it would be kinda hilarious how obvious the trajectory is if it were not so terrifying
Bill Gates is an evil country and he can go fuck his self
My threat list:
1) Billionaire oligarchs
2) Social Media brainwashing
3) Right-Wing extremism
4) Wars
And as many wars are started by right-wing extremists, that came into power by mass manipulation in social media that are in the hands of billionaire oligarchs, I would say the first and foremost global threat and source of all these evils are BILLIONAIRE OLIGARCHS.
I think useful general AI is going to be like flying cars, always just around the corner. The fears of AI improving exponentially have yet to appear and what we have now makes things up half the time and doesn’t understand what it’s saying/drawing, it’s just a complex regurgitator.
The only thing AI is a threat to is our positively mediaeval notion that the average person needs a job in order to deserve income.
UBI is entirely possible. Distributing labor-free money to consumers would allow all of us to receive more goods and services while working less. The logical result of new technologies like AI being invented is that the UBI should increase, allowing the employment level to go down. Robots and AI *should* be enabling prosperous unemployment already, but they simply can’t because our UBI is missing.
Any amount of UBI we can sustain higher than $0 without inflation is equivalent with a boost in real income and market performance. That is a mathematical fact. There’s no economics-based argument against UBI; it improves consumer outcomes almost by definition.
The only thing standing in the way of greater income and greater leisure time for the average person is our culture’s backwards attitudes about jobs, labor and technology. We envision the economy as a giant workplace to fill up with billions of jobs; we aren’t even *trying* to use our technology to save labor and discover a more optimal labor/leisure balance.
The idea that AI should be feared because it might “steal our jobs” is evidence of just how confused our society is about what a job even is. A job isn’t a benefit, it’s a cost to our time and personal freedom which we are compensated for in the form of a wage.
Jobs are useful, but it *never* made sense to maximize the occurrence of jobs or to restrict income to the tune of wages. This is tantamount to wasting people’s time and keeping people needlessly poor.
We need an ample and properly calibrated UBI, to allow people all the leisure time that the modern market economies actually make possible. We should have implemented UBI around the start of the Industrial Revolution; by now it is long overdue.
Sure is he gonna spend his billions to do anything about it, or just get paid to give unwanted advice by media corporations?
AI is somewhere down in the list at 10+ issues.
But billionaires keep using it as a distraction.
And unlike all the other issues, it also comes with massive benefits at the same time.