Basically, the auto industry is heavily unproductive and the protections don’t add/create value to the economy since the industry can’t effectively survive/operate at it’s current scale without government support. The removal of protections generally just means that employment and growth is reallocated more productive sectors and thus there’s no drop in employment rates or economic indicators after auto-industry protections are removed etc. Though generally the auto-industry and manufacturers are given special treatment by governments and voters and prioritized over other forms of employment because the manufacturing jobs looks good on paper, but outside of that longstanding political support, it doesn’t yield a material economic advantage.
On the subject of China and EV’s, while the Chinese government has a horrendous reputation (and for good reason), it’s really no different than subsidized Japanese vehicles in Western markets during the pat 30 years etc. which pundits were extremely worried about. The focus on EV subsidies in North America if anything highlights the car dependency of North American economies and the need to develop more transit-oriented infrastructure and more dense mixed-use commercial/residential hybrid neighborhoods.
Even then, if people just want to continue our subsidies because they’re afraid of China dominating the EV market, the truth is that China’s commercial practices in that market are unsustainable while they’re recording record losses in the process. They’re effectively dependent on heavy Chinese governments subsidies, artificially low labor costs and over-production to remain competitive. China is producing so many EV’s to the extent that millions are sitting unsold, collecting rust. It’s going to be difficult for the Chinese government to keep supporting it’s auto-industry’s over-production if the economy as a whole is suffering from stagnation and a housing/affordability crisis worse than their richer peers etc.
However, while economically, China’s EV practices aren’t sustainable & the Canadian economy and consumers would benefit from phasing out protections, generally politically it’s a dicey move. We might have to wait until things settle down before a government could have the political capital to phase out it’s auto-industry tariffs & subsidies similar to Australia.
Canuck-overseas on
We should be making long term deals with ALLIES, like Japan, South Korea, maybe even European car makers…. To build EVs in Canada.
annonymous_bosch on
I think the suggestion to get China to open up factories in Canada / engage in joint ventures that would develop our industry while also providing cheaper, better EVs to Canadians makes a lot of sense. China is demonstrably streets ahead of western automakers when it comes to EVs, eg they’re about to launch 5 minutes charging, while we have been subsidizing crappy Teslas that fall apart or sometimes cook their passengers alive (and looks like they’ve been cheating on those subsidies too). This may also enable us to negotiate down or out some of the tariffs China has put up on Canadian exports. It’s a win win, and as a bonus it’ll piss Trump off.
aaffpp on
We need to treat the Koreans and Chinese like we do the Japanese and get them to build plants here. There are many different kind of vehicles, from scooters to small cars and small trucks, that would be useful for Canadians. No one should have to pay 65,000 for a pick-up truck that will last only a about 10 years.
Sad_Imagination6012 on
Nope. China is not our friend. Let’s not harm our auto industry even more by bringing in the CCP’s heavily discounted EVs meant to give China global market share lead.
LiGuangMing1981 on
No need to drop the tariffs entirely, but aligning with the more reasonable EU policies makes a lot of sense, and that’s what Canada should have done in the first place.
The 100% tariff was 100% US ass kissing, and look where that got us.
RunRabbitRun902 on
The Koreans seem very interested in helping us with military equipment and manufacturing. Perhaps we should pursue a deal with the ROK; they are a great example of a nation that wanted to move away from purchasing American equipment due to constant price increases. They developed quite a comprehensive, Korean-made vehicle and equipment sector.
I think budding up with the Koreans and getting some insight from them would be wise.
FormerlyShawnHawaii on
The Chinese EVs could be sold at much more affordable price points than our Canadian produced vehicles. We need to get that part right to not disrupt industry that provides jobs.
Otherwise I’m down. Yes China exexuted a bunch of Canadians recently but they were also former Chinese nationals. Not like China offed some Canadian born citizens (as I understand).
ForeignExpression on
Yes, I want to buy a car, and I will never be able to afford a 75,000 dollar North American monster truck. We should be able to buy cars for 20,000 like our parents got to. China sells great electric cars for this much and less. Our industry had decades of warnings to move into electric and all they did was lobby our government to ensure they never had to meet efficiency standards or fuel standards or electrify and here we are decades later. North American car makers are still dedicated by and large to the largest, heaviest, most expensive, inefficient types of vehicles that are are awful for cities and a human-centric way of life. To hell with them. This is like putting a tariff on the internet to preserve our local telegraph industry which refuses to progress. It’s doomed to fail in the long run.
t. man who had to wait to import a 2nd gen 2010 toyota century.
ghost_n_the_shell on
1.) *”If we wanted to have a targeted response to the Trump administration into his biggest financial supporter, we don’t have to tariff Tesla or American EVs…. We would just have to take off the tariff on the Chinese.”*
No thank you. I’d rather send Musk a message.
2.) *”Kingston said he’s confident Canada will be able to produce competitively priced EVs if it’s given time to catch up to China.*
*”North Americans love to drive larger vehicles, pickup trucks and SUVs. You’re seeing electrified formats of those vehicles with increasingly large ranges,” he said. “So yes, the options to Canadians are getting better every single day, and prices over time will become increasingly competitive.”*
BULLSHIT. Prices haven’t really come back down from the egregious Covid-inflated pricing, and I’m expected to believe the auto makers will give the people an affordable car? Out of what? Good will?
I can’t call bullshit hard enough here.
postusa2 on
China is an authoritarian state with an abysmal record on human rights…. but they’ve never threatened to annex us. Dropping our tariffs on EVs is not a matter of if they are our friend or not. We import many other things from China, and this was specifically us trying to be buddies with the US and show we are protecting our joint auto interests.
BYD, MG – all the things that are selling in Europe? Let’s have them on the market here.
espomar on
It should be used as a threat, at least.
If Trump wants to take our industries, for sure the Chinese would come in and build factories for BYD and Geely cars to replace them.
14 Comments
No china is not our friend. Just because you’re in an argument with a good friend doesn’t mean you can suddenly trust your enemies.
Personally, I’m of the opinion that we should be following [Australia’s example](https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/article-does-a-country-have-no-choice-but-to-subsidize-its-auto-industry-ask/) and phasing out all auto-industry tariffs & subsidies. However, I think that now isn’t the best time politically to be doing that since we’d appear to be selling out to Trump (but it is something governments should consider down the line).
Basically, the auto industry is heavily unproductive and the protections don’t add/create value to the economy since the industry can’t effectively survive/operate at it’s current scale without government support. The removal of protections generally just means that employment and growth is reallocated more productive sectors and thus there’s no drop in employment rates or economic indicators after auto-industry protections are removed etc. Though generally the auto-industry and manufacturers are given special treatment by governments and voters and prioritized over other forms of employment because the manufacturing jobs looks good on paper, but outside of that longstanding political support, it doesn’t yield a material economic advantage.
On the subject of China and EV’s, while the Chinese government has a horrendous reputation (and for good reason), it’s really no different than subsidized Japanese vehicles in Western markets during the pat 30 years etc. which pundits were extremely worried about. The focus on EV subsidies in North America if anything highlights the car dependency of North American economies and the need to develop more transit-oriented infrastructure and more dense mixed-use commercial/residential hybrid neighborhoods.
Even then, if people just want to continue our subsidies because they’re afraid of China dominating the EV market, the truth is that China’s commercial practices in that market are unsustainable while they’re recording record losses in the process. They’re effectively dependent on heavy Chinese governments subsidies, artificially low labor costs and over-production to remain competitive. China is producing so many EV’s to the extent that millions are sitting unsold, collecting rust. It’s going to be difficult for the Chinese government to keep supporting it’s auto-industry’s over-production if the economy as a whole is suffering from stagnation and a housing/affordability crisis worse than their richer peers etc.
However, while economically, China’s EV practices aren’t sustainable & the Canadian economy and consumers would benefit from phasing out protections, generally politically it’s a dicey move. We might have to wait until things settle down before a government could have the political capital to phase out it’s auto-industry tariffs & subsidies similar to Australia.
We should be making long term deals with ALLIES, like Japan, South Korea, maybe even European car makers…. To build EVs in Canada.
I think the suggestion to get China to open up factories in Canada / engage in joint ventures that would develop our industry while also providing cheaper, better EVs to Canadians makes a lot of sense. China is demonstrably streets ahead of western automakers when it comes to EVs, eg they’re about to launch 5 minutes charging, while we have been subsidizing crappy Teslas that fall apart or sometimes cook their passengers alive (and looks like they’ve been cheating on those subsidies too). This may also enable us to negotiate down or out some of the tariffs China has put up on Canadian exports. It’s a win win, and as a bonus it’ll piss Trump off.
We need to treat the Koreans and Chinese like we do the Japanese and get them to build plants here. There are many different kind of vehicles, from scooters to small cars and small trucks, that would be useful for Canadians. No one should have to pay 65,000 for a pick-up truck that will last only a about 10 years.
Nope. China is not our friend. Let’s not harm our auto industry even more by bringing in the CCP’s heavily discounted EVs meant to give China global market share lead.
No need to drop the tariffs entirely, but aligning with the more reasonable EU policies makes a lot of sense, and that’s what Canada should have done in the first place.
The 100% tariff was 100% US ass kissing, and look where that got us.
The Koreans seem very interested in helping us with military equipment and manufacturing. Perhaps we should pursue a deal with the ROK; they are a great example of a nation that wanted to move away from purchasing American equipment due to constant price increases. They developed quite a comprehensive, Korean-made vehicle and equipment sector.
I think budding up with the Koreans and getting some insight from them would be wise.
The Chinese EVs could be sold at much more affordable price points than our Canadian produced vehicles. We need to get that part right to not disrupt industry that provides jobs.
Otherwise I’m down. Yes China exexuted a bunch of Canadians recently but they were also former Chinese nationals. Not like China offed some Canadian born citizens (as I understand).
Yes, I want to buy a car, and I will never be able to afford a 75,000 dollar North American monster truck. We should be able to buy cars for 20,000 like our parents got to. China sells great electric cars for this much and less. Our industry had decades of warnings to move into electric and all they did was lobby our government to ensure they never had to meet efficiency standards or fuel standards or electrify and here we are decades later. North American car makers are still dedicated by and large to the largest, heaviest, most expensive, inefficient types of vehicles that are are awful for cities and a human-centric way of life. To hell with them. This is like putting a tariff on the internet to preserve our local telegraph industry which refuses to progress. It’s doomed to fail in the long run.
Ok even if we did, unless they build them here, the USA, or Mexico – we still couldn’t import them [because they are not over 15 years old.](https://tc.canada.ca/en/road-transportation/importing-vehicle/importing-vehicle-countries-other-united-states-mexico)
Its a potential criminal offense.
t. man who had to wait to import a 2nd gen 2010 toyota century.
1.) *”If we wanted to have a targeted response to the Trump administration into his biggest financial supporter, we don’t have to tariff Tesla or American EVs…. We would just have to take off the tariff on the Chinese.”*
No thank you. I’d rather send Musk a message.
2.) *”Kingston said he’s confident Canada will be able to produce competitively priced EVs if it’s given time to catch up to China.*
*”North Americans love to drive larger vehicles, pickup trucks and SUVs. You’re seeing electrified formats of those vehicles with increasingly large ranges,” he said. “So yes, the options to Canadians are getting better every single day, and prices over time will become increasingly competitive.”*
BULLSHIT. Prices haven’t really come back down from the egregious Covid-inflated pricing, and I’m expected to believe the auto makers will give the people an affordable car? Out of what? Good will?
I can’t call bullshit hard enough here.
China is an authoritarian state with an abysmal record on human rights…. but they’ve never threatened to annex us. Dropping our tariffs on EVs is not a matter of if they are our friend or not. We import many other things from China, and this was specifically us trying to be buddies with the US and show we are protecting our joint auto interests.
BYD, MG – all the things that are selling in Europe? Let’s have them on the market here.
It should be used as a threat, at least.
If Trump wants to take our industries, for sure the Chinese would come in and build factories for BYD and Geely cars to replace them.