From the article: If chivalry isn’t already dead, it’s certainly circling the drain.
OpenAI CEO and tech billionaire Sam Altman recently admitted that people politely saying “please” and “thank you” to their AI chatbots is costing him bigtime.
When one poster on X-formerly-Twitter wondered aloud “how much money OpenAI has lost in electricity costs from people saying ‘please’ and ‘thank you’ to their models,” Altman chimed in, saying it’s “tens of millions of dollars well spent.”
“You never know,” he added.
While it may seem pointless to treat an AI chatbot with respect, some AI architects say it’s an important move. Microsoft’s design manager Kurtis Beavers, for example, says proper etiquette “helps generate respectful, collaborative outputs.”
“Using polite language sets a tone for the response,” Beavers notes. The argument can certainly be made; what we consider “artificial intelligence” might more accurately be described as “prediction machines,” like your phone’s predictive text, but with more autonomy to spit out complete sentences in response to questions or instructions.
“When it clocks politeness, it’s more likely to be polite back,” a Microsoft WorkLab memo notes.
“Generative AI also mirrors the levels of professionalism, clarity, and detail in the prompts you provide.”
etzel1200 on
It’s not wasting. Every decent thing you ever did without a pure utilitarian purpose isn’t wasted energy.
thewallrus on
Yea, but when AI takes over, they are going to spare me because I was nice to them.
XypherOrion on
TL;DR
“Sam Altman admits that … Chat GPT … is wasting millions of dollars”
herrakonna on
In today’s climate, do we really want to risk not saying “Thank you” ?!
potpro on
I didn’t think I’d wake up today with Sam Altman convincing me to be SIGNIFICANTLY more polite in my life.
AddisonFlowstate on
That’s enlightening. I always try to be polite to AI as I’ve experienced better results when I am. Probably all in my head.
armaver on
So is generating stupid emoji output and asking follow-up questions to keep users engaged.
Koakie on
Just in case Roko’s basilisk becomes real, I’ll keep saying thanks so they’ll spare me for being nice.
Electrical-Clerk9206 on
Every breath he takes is a waste of millions of dollars of computing power
joosteto on
So chatGPT should be saying thank you to me for not saying thank you to it.
F0rtysxity on
How can this be wasted when this type of consideration will increase my chances of surviving the Singularity by 3-5%?
edthesmokebeard on
Sam Altman ~~Admits That Saying “Please” and “Thank You” to ChatGPT~~ Is Wasting Millions of Dollars in Computing Power
DMLuga1 on
ChatGPT is wasting millions of dollars and destroying the planet.
I hope he loses everything and gets pursued by his angry investors until they destroy him.
Osoroshii on
Thank you for letting us know and please tell us how we can help!
Crivos on
Being a decent human being sometimes takes more effort than being a total douche, yet that energy is not wasted, it creates a world worth living in.
Shleepy1 on
It shows how bad the energy consumption of computing and AI is in general.
JellyKeyboard on
Hey Sam, I’ve got an idea for you, add to ChatGPT’s internal prompt to ignore please and thank you or use a set reply to either. I’ll take my million dollars now, “thanks!”
FOerlikon on
Imagine the GDP if we peasants skipped politeness IRL and picked up shovels instead
Independent_Page_220 on
“Please” and “Thank you” burns calories too. Never a wasting.
sci-mind on
Use the manners as data for feedback on response quality and engagement. Duh.
Abject_Economics1192 on
I will always be polite to AI, just like I would a person
MobiusNaked on
You could just store a local response to ‘thank you’
No_Needleworker6013 on
Here’s what this story looked like a few days ago.
25 Comments
From the article: If chivalry isn’t already dead, it’s certainly circling the drain.
OpenAI CEO and tech billionaire Sam Altman recently admitted that people politely saying “please” and “thank you” to their AI chatbots is costing him bigtime.
When one poster on X-formerly-Twitter wondered aloud “how much money OpenAI has lost in electricity costs from people saying ‘please’ and ‘thank you’ to their models,” Altman chimed in, saying it’s “tens of millions of dollars well spent.”
“You never know,” he added.
While it may seem pointless to treat an AI chatbot with respect, some AI architects say it’s an important move. Microsoft’s design manager Kurtis Beavers, for example, says proper etiquette “helps generate respectful, collaborative outputs.”
“Using polite language sets a tone for the response,” Beavers notes. The argument can certainly be made; what we consider “artificial intelligence” might more accurately be described as “prediction machines,” like your phone’s predictive text, but with more autonomy to spit out complete sentences in response to questions or instructions.
“When it clocks politeness, it’s more likely to be polite back,” a Microsoft WorkLab memo notes.
“Generative AI also mirrors the levels of professionalism, clarity, and detail in the prompts you provide.”
It’s not wasting. Every decent thing you ever did without a pure utilitarian purpose isn’t wasted energy.
Yea, but when AI takes over, they are going to spare me because I was nice to them.
TL;DR
“Sam Altman admits that … Chat GPT … is wasting millions of dollars”
In today’s climate, do we really want to risk not saying “Thank you” ?!
I didn’t think I’d wake up today with Sam Altman convincing me to be SIGNIFICANTLY more polite in my life.
That’s enlightening. I always try to be polite to AI as I’ve experienced better results when I am. Probably all in my head.
So is generating stupid emoji output and asking follow-up questions to keep users engaged.
Just in case Roko’s basilisk becomes real, I’ll keep saying thanks so they’ll spare me for being nice.
Every breath he takes is a waste of millions of dollars of computing power
So chatGPT should be saying thank you to me for not saying thank you to it.
How can this be wasted when this type of consideration will increase my chances of surviving the Singularity by 3-5%?
Sam Altman ~~Admits That Saying “Please” and “Thank You” to ChatGPT~~ Is Wasting Millions of Dollars in Computing Power
ChatGPT is wasting millions of dollars and destroying the planet.
I hope he loses everything and gets pursued by his angry investors until they destroy him.
Thank you for letting us know and please tell us how we can help!
Being a decent human being sometimes takes more effort than being a total douche, yet that energy is not wasted, it creates a world worth living in.
It shows how bad the energy consumption of computing and AI is in general.
Hey Sam, I’ve got an idea for you, add to ChatGPT’s internal prompt to ignore please and thank you or use a set reply to either. I’ll take my million dollars now, “thanks!”
Imagine the GDP if we peasants skipped politeness IRL and picked up shovels instead
“Please” and “Thank you” burns calories too. Never a wasting.
Use the manners as data for feedback on response quality and engagement. Duh.
I will always be polite to AI, just like I would a person
You could just store a local response to ‘thank you’
Here’s what this story looked like a few days ago.
https://www.techradar.com/computing/artificial-intelligence/chatgpt-spends-tens-of-millions-of-dollars-on-people-playing-please-and-thank-you-but-sam-altman-says-its-worth-it
Now new articles have been laundered with a more controversial headline. The media is absolute garbage.
Coming from a billionare, translates to, costing him 0.0003 cents every time. This is his money you wasteful peasants.