The argument: post-Singularity, AI will take over all labor, including entrepreneurial labor. Working at or founding a business will no longer provide social mobility. Everyone will have access to ~equally good AI investment advisors, so everyone will make the same rate of return. Therefore, everyone’s existing pre-singularity capital will grow at the same rate. Although the absolute growth rate of the economy may be spectacular, the overall wealth distribution will stay approximately fixed.
I don’t think about these scenarios too often – partly because it’s so hard to predict what will happen after the Singularity, and partly because everything degenerates into crazy science-fiction scenarios so quickly that I burn a little credibility every time I talk about it.
Still, if we’re going to discuss this, we should get it right – so let’s talk crazy science fiction. When I read this essay, I found myself asking three questions. First, why might its prediction fail to pan out? Second, how can we actively prevent it from coming to pass? Third, assuming it does come to pass, how could a smart person maximize their chance of being in the aristocratic capitalist class?”
2000TWLV on
Nah. It isn’t. A.I. starts doing all the work and the proceeds, monetary or otherwise, are distributed equitably among all people .
There, I did it.
The problem is: how do we wrest control of AI from the oligarchs, the megacorps and their political toadies? Or, at least, how does this happen without first requiring a global catastrophe?
Bananawamajama on
Its easier to imagine that everyone else is too stupid or too limited to understand you than it is to imagine that people have complex nuanced reasons for not agreeing with you.
EndOfTheLine00 on
Maybe I just have a very limited inagination but I honestly don’t know what I’d do without a job.
I am not interested in starting a family.
I am not interested in volunteering.
I have no creative talent.
I guess Id just read books for the rest of my life? Point is I need a goal, one given to me by others and that gets me praise for doing (and ideally doesn’t involve me doing a lot of talking to people) Where do I get it if not a job?
4 Comments
Submission statement: “[*No Set Gauge*](https://nosetgauge.substack.com/) has a great essay on [Capital, AGI, and Human Ambition](https://nosetgauge.substack.com/p/capital-agi-and-human-ambition), where he argues that if humankind survives the Singularity, the likely result is a future of eternal stagnant wealth inequality.
The argument: post-Singularity, AI will take over all labor, including entrepreneurial labor. Working at or founding a business will no longer provide social mobility. Everyone will have access to ~equally good AI investment advisors, so everyone will make the same rate of return. Therefore, everyone’s existing pre-singularity capital will grow at the same rate. Although the absolute growth rate of the economy may be spectacular, the overall wealth distribution will stay approximately fixed.
I don’t think about these scenarios too often – partly because it’s so hard to predict what will happen after the Singularity, and partly because everything degenerates into crazy science-fiction scenarios so quickly that I burn a little credibility every time I talk about it.
Still, if we’re going to discuss this, we should get it right – so let’s talk crazy science fiction. When I read this essay, I found myself asking three questions. First, why might its prediction fail to pan out? Second, how can we actively prevent it from coming to pass? Third, assuming it does come to pass, how could a smart person maximize their chance of being in the aristocratic capitalist class?”
Nah. It isn’t. A.I. starts doing all the work and the proceeds, monetary or otherwise, are distributed equitably among all people .
There, I did it.
The problem is: how do we wrest control of AI from the oligarchs, the megacorps and their political toadies? Or, at least, how does this happen without first requiring a global catastrophe?
Its easier to imagine that everyone else is too stupid or too limited to understand you than it is to imagine that people have complex nuanced reasons for not agreeing with you.
Maybe I just have a very limited inagination but I honestly don’t know what I’d do without a job.
I am not interested in starting a family.
I am not interested in volunteering.
I have no creative talent.
I guess Id just read books for the rest of my life? Point is I need a goal, one given to me by others and that gets me praise for doing (and ideally doesn’t involve me doing a lot of talking to people) Where do I get it if not a job?